Caffrey v. Brown: New C&P Exams & Why Duty to Assist Isn’t CUE
VA can make a serious mistake while developing your claim without that mistake qualifying as clear and unmistakable error (CUE). In Caffrey v. Brown, 6 Vet. App. 377 (1994), the U.S. Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims held that a breach of VA’s duty to assist cannot establish CUE in a final decision. The distinction matters when a veteran wants to correct an old denial or obtain an earlier effective date.
Caffrey also addresses when VA needs an updated compensation and pension (C&P) examination. Evidence that a disability has worsened may make an earlier examination inadequate. The exam’s age alone, however, does not automatically require a new one. Understanding both holdings helps you identify the problem in your file and choose the right review procedure.
The 30-Second Answer
A missing record or a missing exam is a development problem. It is not, by itself, a clear and unmistakable error. Raise development problems while the decision can still be reviewed, and ask for an updated exam by explaining what has changed — not just how old the last exam is.
- Duty to assist is not CUE — Caffrey holds that a breach of the duty to assist cannot establish CUE in a final decision.
- Changed disability — under 38 CFR § 3.327(a), evidence of a material change, or evidence that the current rating may be incorrect, generally calls for reexamination.
- Exam age — VAOPGCPREC 11-95 explains that the passage of time alone does not require a new exam.
- Start with your file — identify the last exam, what changed afterward, when VA learned about it, and whether a decision has already been issued.
What Happened in Caffrey?
Thomas A. Caffrey appealed a Board of Veterans’ Appeals decision that denied a rating above 50% for his service-connected psychiatric disability and denied an earlier effective date. When the Board decided his appeal in October 1990, it relied on a VA examination from November 28, 1988. Additional evidence — a September 1989 letter from a rehabilitation counselor and a December 1989 psychological evaluation — suggested that his impairment was greater than his rating reflected.
The Court found that VA should have obtained a contemporaneous examination. It also found errors in how the Board handled unemployability and in the Board’s explanation for denying a higher rating. The Court vacated and remanded the increased-rating matter; it did not itself award a higher percentage.
Mr. Caffrey also argued that VA’s failure to obtain private hospital records during earlier proceedings was CUE. The Court rejected that argument and affirmed the earlier-effective-date determination. It explained that a breach of the duty to assist creates an incomplete record rather than an incorrect one, so it cannot supply the basis for CUE.
Source: Caffrey v. Brown, 6 Vet. App. 377, 380–384 (1994).
When Does VA Need an Updated Examination?
38 CFR § 3.327(a) addresses reexaminations needed to verify that a disability still exists or to confirm its current severity. Generally, reexamination is required when evidence indicates a material change in the disability or suggests that the current rating may be incorrect.
Snuffer v. Gober, 10 Vet. App. 400, 403 (1997), applied Caffrey when a veteran reported that his hearing had worsened since his last examination. On those facts, the Court required a new examination. A veteran’s report of observable worsening matters — but the case did not create an automatic two-year expiration rule.
For a veteran seeking an increase, the practical question is this: Does the available evidence adequately describe the disability during the period VA needs to evaluate?
A Hypothetical Migraine Claim
The last exam recorded one disabling episode every few months. While the claim is being developed, the veteran reports several disabling episodes per month, more treatment, and missed work. Those details explain why the earlier exam may no longer describe the disability accurately, and they give VA something specific to evaluate. If acceptable medical evidence already adequately describes the relevant level of disability, another VA examination may be unnecessary (see VAOPGCPREC 11-95, paragraph 18).
Compare that with a request that says only, “My exam is old.” It identifies a date, but it does not explain what has changed or what information is missing.
An Exam Does Not Automatically Expire
VAOPGCPREC 11-95 directly addresses whether the Board must remand a case solely because time has passed since an otherwise adequate exam. The answer is no. Evidence or assertions of worsening can change that analysis.
Palczewski v. Nicholson, 21 Vet. App. 174, 181–183 (2007), also rejected the passage of time alone as a basis for another examination where the claimant had neither identified a change nor alleged worsening. That part of the decision arose in a hearing-loss service-connection claim. It supports the age-alone point, but it does not mean every original service-connection claim is analyzed the same way as an increased-rating claim.
These authorities do not set a universal rule that an exam becomes unusable after one year or two years. Focus your request on what has changed since the examination and why the available evidence does not adequately address it.
How to Explain What Changed
A useful statement makes the comparison easy to follow. Start with the exam date, then explain the difference between your symptoms at that time and your symptoms now.
Depending on the disability, describe:
- How often symptoms occur and how long they last
- What you can no longer do, or can now do only with difficulty
- Changes in treatment, medication, or assistive devices
- Effects on work, sleep, relationships, or daily activities
- The approximate date the change began
Use concrete examples. “I now leave work early twice a month because of these episodes” tells the reader more than “It is much worse.” Include dates and relevant records when you have them. Describe what you actually experience rather than trying to fit your statement to a particular percentage. For more on writing your own statement, see Jandreau v. Nicholson and lay evidence.
Example Request During Claim Development
“My last examination for [condition] was on [date]. Since approximately [date], my symptoms have changed from [earlier symptoms] to [current symptoms]. These changes affect my ability to [specific activities]. Please consider [identified records or statements] and whether an updated examination is necessary to accurately evaluate my disability under 38 CFR § 3.327(a).”
This is an example to adapt to your own facts. Once VA has issued a decision, a statement alone does not take the place of a properly filed review request: under 38 CFR § 3.159(b)(4), evidence submitted after a decision notice must come in through the appropriate review option.
Why a Duty-to-Assist Error Is Different From CUE
The duty to assist concerns VA’s help in developing the evidence needed for a claim. Under 38 CFR § 3.159, that can include reasonable efforts to obtain relevant records and, when needed, an examination or medical opinion.
CUE is a separate, narrow procedure for revising a final decision. Under 38 CFR § 3.105(a), it requires an undebatable error of fact or law that would have manifestly changed the result (Russell v. Principi, 3 Vet. App. 310, 313–314 (1992) (en banc)). Review is based on the record and the law that existed when the decision was made.
Saying “VA should have obtained another exam” identifies a development issue. It does not show what an examination that never happened would have found. Caffrey’s CUE holding prevents that missing evidence from being used to reconstruct the earlier record.
A potentially valid CUE theory must identify a qualifying error in the earlier decision itself. See CUE and earlier effective dates for what a CUE request must include.
Which Decision You Challenge Matters
A final Board decision is subject to separate CUE procedures under 38 U.S.C. § 7111 and 38 CFR §§ 20.1400–20.1411. Section 3.105(a) also bars revising a regional office decision on an issue the Board or a court has already decided on appeal. Both sets of rules exclude a failure to fulfill the duty to assist as a basis for CUE (38 CFR § 20.1403(d), cross-referenced in § 3.105(a)(1)(vi)).
Later Cases Reinforce the CUE Limit
Cook v. Principi, 318 F.3d 1334, 1341, 1344–1347 (Fed. Cir. 2002) (en banc), confirmed that a duty-to-assist breach cannot establish CUE. It also rejected “grave procedural error” as a separate exception to finality. A development failure alone therefore does not keep an otherwise final claim open indefinitely.
Smith v. McDonough, No. 22-2169, slip op. at 8–11 (Fed. Cir. May 20, 2024), clarified that correcting the error must clearly change the outcome on the merits. Showing only that VA should have continued developing or adjudicating the claim, with an uncertain result, is not enough for CUE.
A later change in legal interpretation is also different from an undebatable error under the law at the time. In George v. McDonough, 596 U.S. 740 (2022), the Supreme Court held that the later invalidation of a VA regulation did not establish CUE in a final decision that had applied that regulation.
Which Path Fits Your Situation?
The table below covers common situations under the Appeals Modernization Act (AMA). Check your decision notice for the options and deadlines that apply to you. Caffrey and VAOPGCPREC 11-95 predate this system, so their examination principles must be applied alongside today’s review rules. Older opinions also refer to a “well-grounded claim.” Congress eliminated that threshold in the Veterans Claims Assistance Act of 2000, Pub. L. No. 106-475, § 4, 114 Stat. 2096, 2098–2099; it is not a current filing requirement.
| Your Situation | Path to Examine | What to Identify |
|---|---|---|
| Your initial or increased-rating claim is still being developed | Submit relevant evidence and request an updated assessment | What changed, and why the existing evidence is insufficient |
| An initial or Supplemental Claim decision was issued within the past year, and the existing record shows VA missed needed development | Higher-Level Review | The duty-to-assist error that existed before the decision |
| You need VA to consider new and relevant evidence about a disputed decision | Supplemental Claim | The additional evidence, or the records VA should obtain |
| You disagree with an initial, Supplemental Claim, or Higher-Level Review decision and want a Veterans Law Judge to review it | Board Appeal, generally within one year of the decision notice | The appropriate docket and its evidence rules |
| The old decision is final, and your only allegation is that VA should have obtained records or another exam | That allegation does not establish CUE | Whether another available review path fits your claim |
Higher-Level Review does not accept new evidence. Under 38 CFR § 3.2601(f)–(g), if the reviewer identifies a duty-to-assist error that existed when VA decided the claim and cannot grant the maximum benefit, the claim must be returned for correction and readjudication. A Higher-Level Review decision cannot itself receive another Higher-Level Review; after one, the available VA review options are a Supplemental Claim or a Board Appeal (§ 3.2500(c)(2)).
A substantially complete Supplemental Claim triggers VA’s duty to assist in gathering evidence, including help securing new and relevant evidence. Readjudication requires new and relevant evidence. The examination provision in § 3.159(c)(4) applies to a Supplemental Claim only when new and relevant evidence is presented or secured (§ 3.159(c)(4)(iv)), so it does not guarantee an exam for every filing. See also 38 CFR § 3.2501.
Why the Timing of Worsening Matters
38 U.S.C. § 5103A(e)–(f) separates evidence development from review. The duty to assist does not apply during Higher-Level Review or Board review, but those reviewers must address qualifying earlier failures through the statutory correction process.
In an AMA Board appeal, 38 CFR § 20.802(a) requires a remand for a duty-to-assist error that occurred before the agency decision on appeal, unless the issue can be granted in full. Worsening that began only after that decision does not, by itself, establish an earlier duty-to-assist error.
For example, if VA had evidence of worsening before it decided the claim but failed to obtain a necessary updated examination, that may support a pre-decisional error argument. If the disability became worse only afterward, describe that timing accurately and choose a procedure that allows VA to consider the additional evidence. Do not assume that a Board evidence docket automatically entitles you to a new examination.
The Board Can Remand for Other Legal Errors, Too
The pre-decisional limit on duty-to-assist remands does not describe all of the Board’s remand authority. Gladish v. Collins, 39 Vet. App. 1, 14 (2025), explains that § 20.802(a) separately allows the Board to remand to correct other agency errors in satisfying a statutory or regulatory duty, when correcting the error would have a reasonable possibility of helping substantiate the claim. The Court’s discussion includes notice deficiencies.
Ortega v. Collins, No. 24-4799, slip op. at 15 (Vet. App. Apr. 13, 2026), reiterates that § 20.802(a) gives the Board authority to consider remanding for errors other than duty-to-assist errors. Neither decision makes later worsening, standing alone, a pre-decisional duty-to-assist error, and neither guarantees a new exam. They correct the broader misconception that the Board can remand only for duty-to-assist errors.
Under 38 CFR § 3.2500, the next available step depends on the decision you received. Properly and timely continuing to pursue the issue can keep an earlier claim date in consideration, but it does not guarantee that date. A Supplemental Claim filed more than one year after the decision generally cannot receive an effective date earlier than the date VA received it, subject to applicable exceptions. For more, see protecting an effective date through timely review.
What to Review Before Filing
Tap an item to check it off. Your progress is saved in this browser only.
- Found the most recent C&P examination and its date
- Compared the exam findings with the changes I am reporting
- Identified when those changes began, and whether they predated the decision
- Located relevant treatment records and supporting statements
- Checked what evidence VA had before the decision
- Read the decision notice and identified my review deadline
- Chose a review option that accepts the evidence I need considered
- Explained the specific problem rather than relying only on the exam’s age
For how each review lane works, see the Appeals guide. To get a copy of your exam reports and the evidence VA had, see Requesting Military & VA Records.
Common Questions About New Exams & CUE
Does a two-year-old exam automatically require replacement?
No. VAOPGCPREC 11-95 rejects the passage of time alone as a reason for remand. Identify worsening or another reason the existing evidence is inadequate.
Does a new exam guarantee a higher rating?
No. An updated examination supplies evidence for deciding the claim. Its findings still need to support the benefit you are seeking.
Can I send new medical records with a Higher-Level Review?
No. Higher-Level Review does not accept new evidence. Consider a Supplemental Claim or a Board docket that accepts evidence when additional evidence is needed.
What if my condition worsened after the decision?
Worsening that began after the decision does not, by itself, establish a pre-decisional duty-to-assist error. Consider a procedure that accepts additional evidence, such as a Supplemental Claim if you disagree with the prior decision, or a new claim for an increased rating if the problem is new worsening.
Is failing to order an exam CUE?
No. Under Caffrey v. Brown and 38 CFR § 20.1403(d), a failure in the duty to assist does not establish clear and unmistakable error. Keep that distinction in mind before challenging a final decision.
Legal Authorities
Contemporaneous exams; duty to assist is not CUE
Updated-examination analysis at page 381. A breach of the duty to assist creates an incomplete record, not an incorrect one, and cannot establish CUE (pages 382–384).
Reported worsening since the last exam
A veteran’s report that his hearing had worsened since the last exam required a new examination on the facts presented.
Passage of time alone is not enough
The passage of time alone did not require another examination where the claimant had not identified a change or alleged worsening.
No CUE, no “grave procedural error” exception
Duty-to-assist breaches cannot establish CUE and do not create a separate exception to finality.
CUE must change the merits outcome
CUE requires an error that, once corrected, clearly changes the merits outcome — not merely one that leads to further proceedings.
Later invalidation is not CUE
The later invalidation of a VA regulation did not establish CUE in an earlier final decision that had applied it.
Board remands for other errors
The Board’s AMA remand authority includes certain errors other than duty-to-assist errors, such as notice deficiencies.
Gladish reiterated
Reiterates that § 20.802(a) lets the Board consider remanding for errors other than duty-to-assist errors.
Contemporaneous examination requirement
The passage of time alone does not require a new examination; a claimed increase in severity since the exam can.
Reexaminations
Reexamination when evidence indicates a material change in a disability or that the current rating may be incorrect.
When the duty to assist applies
Limits the duty to assist to the period before the agency decision and sets out how Higher-Level Review and the Board correct earlier development errors.
Duty to notify and assist
How VA assists in developing claims, when it provides exams, and why evidence after a decision must come in through a review option (paragraph (b)(4)).
Revision for clear and unmistakable error
The CUE standard for agency decisions, the record reviewed, and the limit on revising issues already decided by the Board or a court.
What is (and is not) CUE
Examples of what is not CUE, including the failure to fulfill the duty to assist. Section 3.105(a)(1)(vi) cross-references this rule.
Review options and continuous pursuit
The review options after each type of decision, continuous pursuit, and the effective-date rules for timely and late filings.
Supplemental Claims
New and relevant evidence, the evidentiary record, and when the duty to assist applies to a Supplemental Claim.
Higher-Level Review
The closed evidentiary record in Higher-Level Review and the return of claims for pre-decisional duty-to-assist errors.
Board remands under the AMA
Mandatory remand for pre-decisional duty-to-assist errors, and discretionary remand for other errors that could help substantiate the claim.
Where to Go Next
An exam problem is one piece of a claim. These guides cover the pieces around it.
Appealing a Decision
Supplemental Claim, Higher-Level Review, or Board — the deadlines, the evidence rules, and how to choose a review option.
Read the Guide →C&P Exams
How to prepare for the examination, get a copy of your DBQ, and respond when the report is wrong or incomplete.
Read the Guide →Rudd v. Nicholson
Trying to revisit an old effective date? Why a freestanding claim is barred, and which narrow paths — including CUE — remain.
Read the Article →Lay Evidence & Your Own Statement
When your description of worsening symptoms is competent evidence, plus copy-and-edit statement templates.
Read the Article →CFR
Plain-English summaries of § 3.159 (duty to assist), § 3.105 (CUE), and the other rules cited in this article.
Read the Guide →Case Law Reference
The court decisions that set binding standards VA must follow — including Caffrey, Rudd, and Calhoun.
Read the Guide →Before You File
An accredited representative can review your examination reports, claim history, and deadlines before you choose a path. VSOs help for free; accredited attorneys and claims agents generally may charge fees only for work after VA issues an initial decision. Find one through the VA accreditation search or the contacts on the Resources page.
This article provides educational information, not legal advice. Every VA disability claim depends on its individual facts and evidence.