Official Text of 38 CFR § 3.310

Below is the complete, current text of the regulation, reproduced from the Electronic Code of Federal Regulations (federal regulations are public domain). A plain-English breakdown follows the box.

Official text of 38 CFR § 3.310

§ 3.310 Disabilities that are proximately due to, or aggravated by, service-connected disease or injury.

(a) General. Except as provided in § 3.300(c), disability which is proximately due to or the result of a service-connected disease or injury shall be service connected. When service connection is thus established for a secondary condition, the secondary condition shall be considered a part of the original condition.

(b) Aggravation of nonservice-connected disabilities. Any increase in severity of a nonservice-connected disease or injury that is proximately due to or the result of a service-connected disease or injury, and not due to the natural progress of the nonservice-connected disease, will be service connected. However, VA will not concede that a nonservice-connected disease or injury was aggravated by a service-connected disease or injury unless the baseline level of severity of the nonservice-connected disease or injury is established by medical evidence created before the onset of aggravation or by the earliest medical evidence created at any time between the onset of aggravation and the receipt of medical evidence establishing the current level of severity of the nonservice-connected disease or injury. The rating activity will determine the baseline and current levels of severity under the Schedule for Rating Disabilities (38 CFR part 4) and determine the extent of aggravation by deducting the baseline level of severity, as well as any increase in severity due to the natural progress of the disease, from the current level.

(Authority: 38 U.S.C. 1110 and 1131)

(c) Cardiovascular disease. Ischemic heart disease or other cardiovascular disease developing in a veteran who has a service-connected amputation of one lower extremity at or above the knee or service-connected amputations of both lower extremities at or above the ankles, shall be held to be the proximate result of the service-connected amputation or amputations.

(d) Traumatic brain injury. (1) In a veteran who has a service-connected traumatic brain injury, the following shall be held to be the proximate result of the service-connected traumatic brain injury (TBI), in the absence of clear evidence to the contrary:

(i) Parkinsonism, including Parkinson's disease, following moderate or severe TBI;

(ii) Unprovoked seizures following moderate or severe TBI;

(iii) Dementias of the following types: presenile dementia of the Alzheimer type, frontotemporal dementia, and dementia with Lewy bodies, if manifest within 15 years following moderate or severe TBI;

(iv) Depression if manifest within 3 years of moderate or severe TBI, or within 12 months of mild TBI; or

(v) Diseases of hormone deficiency that result from hypothalamo-pituitary changes if manifest within 12 months of moderate or severe TBI.

(2) Neither the severity levels nor the time limits in paragraph (d)(1) of this section preclude a finding of service connection for conditions shown by evidence to be proximately due to service-connected TBI. If a claim does not meet the requirements of paragraph (d)(1) with respect to the time of manifestation or the severity of the TBI, or both, VA will develop and decide the claim under generally applicable principles of service connection without regard to paragraph (d)(1).

(3)(i) For purposes of this section VA will use the following table for determining the severity of a TBI:

MildModerateSevere
Normal structural imagingNormal or abnormal structural imagingNormal or abnormal structural imaging.
LOC = 0-30 minLOC > 30 min and < 24 hoursLOC > 24 hrs.
AOC = a moment up to 24 hrsAOC > 24 hours. Severity based on other criteria.
PTA = 0-1 dayPTA > 1 and < 7 daysPTA > 7 days.
GCS = 13-15GCS = 9-12GCS = 3-8.

Note: The factors considered are: Structural imaging of the brain. LOC—Loss of consciousness. AOC—Alteration of consciousness/mental state. PTA—Post-traumatic amnesia. GCS—Glasgow Coma Scale. (For purposes of injury stratification, the Glasgow Coma Scale is measured at or after 24 hours.)

(ii) The determination of the severity level under this paragraph is based on the TBI symptoms at the time of injury or shortly thereafter, rather than the current level of functioning. VA will not require that the TBI meet all the criteria listed under a certain severity level in order to classify the TBI at that severity level. If a TBI meets the criteria in more than one category of severity, then VA will rank the TBI at the highest level in which a criterion is met, except where the qualifying criterion is the same at both levels.

(Authority: 38 U.S.C. 501, 1110 and 1131)

[44 FR 50340, Aug. 28, 1979, as amended at 66 FR 18198, Apr. 6, 2001; 71 FR 52747, Sept. 7, 2006; 78 FR 76208, Dec. 17, 2013]

What § 3.310 Means in Plain English

Read or verify the current version on the official eCFR: 38 CFR § 3.310. Text above is current as of October 2026.

What Secondary Service Connection Actually Means

💡

Starting With a PACT Act Grant?

A presumptive PACT Act disability can serve as the primary service-connected condition. The focused article PACT Act Secondary Conditions: Building on a Presumptive Grant (38 CFR 3.310) explains how this guide's rules apply after the presumptive grant.

Most veterans understand direct service connection: something happened in service, you have a current diagnosis, and a medical opinion links the two. That is the Caluza Triangle — current disability, in-service event, and nexus between them.

Secondary service connection works differently. You do not have to connect the new condition back to your military service at all. Instead, you connect it to a disability that is already service-connected. The law treats a disability that results from a service-connected condition as if it were itself incurred in service. The chain looks like this:

The Secondary Service Connection Chain

1
A primary condition is already service-connected (directly, presumptively, or even itself secondarily)
2
A new, separate condition develops that is caused or aggravated by that primary condition
3
A medical nexus opinion explains the relationship at the "at least as likely as not" level
4
The VA grants the secondary condition its own separate rating, which combines with the primary under the whole-person formula
You never re-prove anything about your service. The primary service connection does that work for you. This is why secondary claims are often the fastest way to raise a combined rating.

The practical impact is large. A primary condition rated at 10% can become the legal foundation for a secondary condition rated at 30%, 50%, or more — and the two ratings stack under the combined ratings formula. Whole families of conditions that would be impossible to connect directly to service decades later become straightforward once the chain is understood.

🔗

This Guide Is an Independent Explainer

The VA's own regulation governing secondary claims is 38 CFR § 3.310 on the official eCFR. Nothing here is legal or medical advice — it is education to help you have a more informed conversation with your physician and your VSO.

Caused By vs. Aggravated By — The Distinction That Confuses Everyone

This single distinction trips up more veterans than almost anything else in the secondary-claims world. 38 CFR § 3.310 actually authorizes two completely different theories of secondary connection, and they have different evidence requirements and different rating consequences. Understanding which one your claim relies on changes how you build it.

TWO THEORIES UNDER 38 CFR § 3.310 CAUSED BY (§ 3.310(a)) the primary condition creates a brand-new condition service- connected causes NEW condition Rated on its full severity. No deduction. The whole disability is service-connected. AGGRAVATED BY (§ 3.310(b)) the primary condition worsens an already-existing condition natural baseline aggravation begins Only the additional worsening above the established baseline is compensated. The baseline level is deducted.

Figure: The two secondary theories. Causation means your service-connected disability produced an entirely new condition that would not otherwise exist — the new condition is rated in full. Aggravation means a condition you already had (and which is not itself service-connected) was made worse by a service-connected disability — and only that extra increment of worsening is compensated, after the VA establishes and subtracts a "baseline" level. The worsening does not have to be permanent.

"Caused By" — § 3.310(a)

  • The service-connected condition created a new disability that did not exist before
  • Example: service-connected diabetes causes peripheral neuropathy
  • The secondary condition is rated on its full current severity
  • No baseline is subtracted — the entire disability is service-connected
  • Nexus language: "at least as likely as not caused by"

"Aggravated By" — § 3.310(b)

  • A non-service-connected condition existed already, and the service-connected condition worsened it — any increase in severity counts, and it does not have to be permanent
  • Example: service-connected knee disability worsens pre-existing osteoarthritis in the opposite knee
  • Only the added worsening above the medically established baseline is compensated
  • The VA must establish that baseline using the earliest medical evidence available
  • Nexus language: "at least as likely as not aggravated by" — that is, worse than it would be without the service-connected condition
⚠️

Why the Distinction Matters for Your Pay

Veterans routinely lose value by claiming only "caused by" when the honest medical picture is aggravation — or by accepting an aggravation grant without challenging an inflated baseline. If your condition pre-existed but got materially worse because of a service-connected disability, claim it as aggravation. If the VA grants aggravation, scrutinize the baseline they assigned: the higher the baseline they claim, the less they pay. The baseline must be supported by actual medical evidence of your condition's severity before the aggravation began, not assumed.

⚖️

Secondary Aggravation Does Not Have to Be Permanent

Older guidance — and many examiner opinions — still ask whether a condition was "permanently aggravated." That is the wrong test for § 3.310(b). In Ward v. Wilkie, 31 Vet. App. 233 (2019), the Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims held that the "permanent worsening" standard does not apply to secondary aggravation: any increase in severity of a non-service-connected condition caused by a service-connected disability counts, including temporary flare-ups. VA proposed a rule in 2020 to change this, but it was never finalized — § 3.310 has not been amended since 2013 — and VA's own adjudication manual (M21-1 V.ii.2.D) states that permanent worsening is not required.

Separately, after Spicer v. McDonough, 61 F.4th 1360 (Fed. Cir. 2023), the manual instructs raters to apply a "but-for" standard — was the condition worse than it would have been but for the service-connected disability, including where it interfered with treatment — and to no longer deduct "natural progress," even though the regulation's text still mentions it. The baseline requirement remains: VA still needs evidence of how severe the condition was before the aggravation. See the M21-1 index entry.

Don't mix this up with in-service aggravation. For a condition that existed before you entered service and got worse during service, 38 CFR § 3.306 applies, and temporary flare-ups during service generally are not enough — that rule asks for an increase in the underlying disability. The "not permanent" rule above is for § 3.310(b) secondary aggravation only.

The Legal Foundation: 38 CFR § 3.310

Every secondary claim lives or dies on 38 CFR § 3.310. The regulation is short, but each clause matters:

How § 3.310 Connects to the Rest of the Legal Framework

Secondary service connection does not stand alone. It sits inside a web of regulations and case law that every well-built claim should reference:

Foundation

The Caluza Triangle

A secondary claim is still a service-connection claim, so it still needs the three Caluza elements — but the "in-service event" element is satisfied by the primary service-connected condition rather than by an event in service. Read the full framework on the Caluza Triangle page.

Regulations

38 CFR & M21-1

§ 3.310 works alongside § 3.102 (benefit of the doubt), § 3.159 (duty to assist), and the M21-1 adjudication manual sections that tell raters how to develop secondary claims. The full list is on the CFR & M21-1 page.

Case Law

Precedent That Controls Secondaries

Allen v. Brown, 7 Vet. App. 439 (1995) established that aggravation of a non-service-connected condition is compensable — the case that put teeth into § 3.310(b). Ward v. Wilkie (2019) held that secondary aggravation need not be permanent, and Spicer v. McDonough (Fed. Cir. 2023) confirmed the broad "but-for" reach of secondary service connection. El-Amin, Wallin, and others refine the nexus requirement. See the Case Law page.

Evidence Tools

DBQs & Nexus Opinions

A secondary claim is won on the medical opinion. The right Disability Benefits Questionnaire — completed by a specialist who addresses the secondary relationship directly — is often the single most decisive document in the file.

The Four Elements of a Secondary Claim

The Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims describes three legal elements of secondary service connection — a current disability, a service-connected disability, and medical evidence of a nexus between them (Wallin v. West, 11 Vet. App. 509 (1998)). In practice, the evidence has to establish four things. Miss any one and the claim stalls:

What the VA Must See

1
An established primary. The condition you are building from must already be service-connected. Confirm its diagnostic code and rating from your decision letter.
2
A current secondary diagnosis. A licensed provider must have formally diagnosed the new condition. A symptom is not a diagnosis.
3
A medical nexus. An opinion stating it is "at least as likely as not" that the primary condition caused or aggravated the secondary — with the mechanism explained, not just asserted.
4
A plausible medical relationship. The claimed link has to make medical sense. This is the element most veterans underweight — and the focus of the rest of this guide.
💡

Secondary Claims Require No New Service Evidence

You never go back and re-prove your military service for a secondary claim. The service link is already carried by the primary condition. You need only the current diagnosis and a nexus opinion connecting it to the established primary. This is why a secondary claim filed years after discharge can still succeed where a fresh direct claim could not.

The Medical Relationship Philosophy — Plausible, Not Limitless

Here is the idea that should anchor every secondary claim you ever file:

A secondary condition requires a medically plausible relationship — a real, explainable mechanism by which the primary condition produces or worsens the secondary.

It does not rest on the idea that "anything can cause anything."

That nuance is the difference between a credible claim and one that gets dismissed as speculative. The VA — and any honest physician — will look for a mechanism: a pathway through which condition A leads to condition B. "I have both conditions, so one must have caused the other" is not a mechanism; it is a coincidence argument, and raters are trained to reject it.

When the mechanism is well-documented in medical literature, the relationship is easy to defend. When it is plausible but less studied, the claim is still winnable — it just needs a stronger, more individualized nexus letter. And when the asserted link has no real mechanism at all, no amount of paperwork will save it, and filing it can erode your credibility on the claims that do have merit.

This is why the most useful skill in secondary claims is learning to grade the strength of the relationship before you file. The next section does exactly that.

Strength of Evidence: Strong, Moderate, and Weak Relationships

Not all secondary relationships are created equal. The medical literature supports some connections overwhelmingly, treats others as real-but-bidirectional associations, and offers little support for a third group that veterans nonetheless attempt frequently. Grading a pairing honestly tells you how much evidence you need to bring:

Strongly Established Relationships

These pairings rest on the strongest published medical evidence and clear physiologic mechanisms. Each entry pairs the relationship with a primary, peer-reviewed source a physician can cite directly. Links open the source's full text or PubMed record in a new tab.

Strongly Established

Guideline- or Meta-Analysis-Level Support
Diabetes mellitus → Peripheral neuropathy Strong

Chronic hyperglycemia damages peripheral nerves, producing the classic "stocking-glove" distal symmetric polyneuropathy. The American Diabetes Association recommends assessing every Type 2 patient for neuropathy at diagnosis and at least annually thereafter; each affected extremity is separately ratable.

ADA Professional Practice Committee. “12. Retinopathy, Neuropathy, and Foot Care: Standards of Care in Diabetes—2024.” Diabetes Care 2024;47(Suppl 1):S231–S243. Standards of Care — Neuropathy & Foot Care — PMC full text.

Allergic / chronic rhinitis → Asthma Strong

The "united airway" relationship: rhinitis commonly precedes and predicts asthma. In a meta-analysis, a history of allergic rhinitis was associated with roughly 3.8-fold higher odds of asthma (OR 3.82).

Tohidinik HR, et al. World Allergy Organ J. 2019;12(10):100069. Meta-analysis of 29 studies / 274,489 subjects — PMC full text.

PTSD → Sleep disturbance / insomnia Strong

Sleep disturbance is so intrinsic to PTSD that nightmares and sleep disturbance are diagnostic criteria in the DSM-5. Hyperarousal and disrupted REM regulation directly degrade sleep — one of the most firmly established relationships in the secondary world.

American Psychiatric Association. DSM-5-TR (2022), PTSD Criterion B2 (distressing dreams) and Criterion E6 (sleep disturbance). VA National Center for PTSD — sleep problems overview.

Asthma → Obstructive sleep apnea Strong

In a meta-analysis, adults with asthma had about 2.6-fold higher odds of having OSA than those without asthma (DC 6847). Proposed contributors include obesity, airway inflammation, nasal disease, and inhaled or oral steroid use; the authors note that proof of a causal relationship is still lacking, so the nexus should explain the mechanism in your case.

Kong DL, et al. Sci Rep 2017;7(1):4088. Meta-analysis of 26 studies / 7,675 patients — PMC full text.

Orthopedic injury → Radiculopathy Strong

A service-connected spine disability that narrows the neural foramina or herniates a disc compresses the nerve root, producing radiating limb symptoms. Radiculopathy is rated separately under the peripheral-nerve codes (e.g., DC 8520 for the sciatic nerve) and is, in effect, the neurologic extension of the orthopedic condition.

38 CFR § 4.124a — Schedule of ratings, neurological conditions. eCFR — peripheral-nerve diagnostic codes.

Hypertension → Chronic kidney disease Strong

High arterial pressure damages the kidney's small vessels and glomeruli, progressively reducing filtration. In a meta-analysis of 2.38 million people, a systolic pressure of 140 or higher was associated with roughly 1.6- to 2.1-fold higher risk of chronic kidney disease or end-stage renal disease compared with ideal blood pressure.

Weldegiorgis M, Woodward M. BMC Nephrol 2020;21(1):506. Systematic review / meta-analysis (>2.3M people) — PMC full text.

Commonly Explored Relationships

These connections are real and routinely granted, but the literature describes them as consistent associations — often bidirectional — rather than proven one-directional causation. They are well worth pursuing; they simply call for a nexus letter that explains the mechanism in your individual case rather than asserting certainty.

Commonly Explored

Consistent Association — Individualized Nexus Advised
PTSD → Obstructive sleep apnea Moderate

A heavily litigated pairing. The most defensible version routes through an intermediary (see below): PTSD disrupts sleep and can drive weight gain, and obesity is a major OSA risk factor. In a study of Iraq and Afghanistan veterans seeking PTSD treatment, 69% screened high-risk for OSA and greater PTSD severity predicted a positive screen — but causation is debated, so frame it carefully. See the Sleep Apnea guide for the full literature.

Colvonen PJ, et al. J Clin Sleep Med 2015;11(5):513–518. OSA risk in OEF/OIF/OND veterans with PTSD — PMC full text.

PTSD → Migraine / headache Moderate

PTSD and migraine co-occur far above chance — people with episodic migraine have about 3–4-fold higher odds of PTSD. Proposed shared mechanisms include stress-hormone (HPA-axis) and autonomic dysfunction, low serotonin and norepinephrine, and central sensitization. Because the direction of the relationship is not settled, a nexus should explain the mechanism in your case rather than claim simple cause.

Peterlin BL, et al. Headache 2011;51(6):860–868. Review of PTSD and migraine comorbidity — PMC full text.

Chronic pain → Depression Moderate

Living with a painful service-connected musculoskeletal condition is a well-documented driver of depression; the two interact bidirectionally and amplify each other. Frame as a documented comorbidity with a clear functional pathway (pain → disability → mood).

Bair MJ, et al. Arch Intern Med 2003;163(20):2433–2445. Landmark literature review on depression–pain comorbidity — PubMed.

GERD → Obstructive sleep apnea Moderate

Nocturnal reflux and OSA frequently coexist and may worsen one another through airway irritation and intrathoracic pressure swings, but the direction of causation is genuinely unsettled — a textbook bidirectional association (a meta-analysis of 7 studies and 2,699 patients found a pooled odds ratio of 1.75).

Wu ZH, et al. Sleep Breath 2019;23(2):389–397. Meta-analysis of OSAHS and GERD — PMC full text.

Allergic rhinitis → Chronic sinusitis Moderate

Allergic rhinitis frequently coexists with chronic rhinosinusitis and may aggravate it through shared mucosal inflammation. The leading guideline (EPOS 2020) finds that allergy plays an important role in some subtypes (allergic fungal rhinosinusitis and central compartment atopic disease) but does not establish it as a general cause — an aggravation theory is often the better fit.

Fokkens WJ, et al. Rhinology 2020;58(Suppl S29):1–464. European Position Paper on Rhinosinusitis (EPOS 2020) — PubMed.

Weak or Controversial Relationships

These are pairings veterans attempt often but that lack robust published causal support. They are not automatically impossible — but they require an exceptionally well-reasoned, individualized medical opinion, and they usually fail without one. Listing them here is not discouragement; it is so you bring the right level of evidence and protect your credibility.

Weak / Controversial

Thin Literature — Bring an Exceptional Nexus or Reconsider
Tinnitus → Hypertension Weak

Frequently claimed, rarely granted on causation. Any association is confounded by shared age and vascular risk factors, and there is no accepted mechanism by which ringing in the ears raises systemic blood pressure. The stronger argument, if any, runs the other direction.

Caution: treat as a long-shot causation theory. A bare assertion will be rejected as speculative.

Tinnitus → Erectile dysfunction Weak

No plausible physiologic pathway connects tinnitus to vascular or neurogenic erectile dysfunction. Where ED is secondary, it is usually to a mental-health condition (or its medication) or to a vascular/endocrine disease — not to tinnitus itself.

Caution: reframe to the actual mechanism (e.g., ED secondary to service-connected depression or its SSRI treatment) rather than to tinnitus.

A condition "secondary to" an unrelated condition by coincidence Weak

The classic failure mode: "I have condition A and condition B, so A must have caused B." Without a mechanism, this is the "anything causes anything" argument the VA is trained to reject. If you cannot articulate how A produces B, the claim is not ready.

Caution: identify the real intermediary or mechanism first; if none exists, consider a direct or presumptive theory instead.

A note on these grades: A Moderate or even Weak label does not doom a claim — it tells you how much medical firepower to bring. Moderate relationships are won every day with a mechanism-driven specialist opinion. Weak ones can occasionally succeed with extraordinary individualized evidence. What fails reliably is a strong-sounding assertion with no mechanism behind it.

Intermediary Conditions: The Chain Reaction

Some of the most valuable secondary claims are not a single step but a chain — the primary condition causes an intermediary condition, which in turn causes the condition you are claiming. Very few resources explain this well, yet it is exactly how the VA and the medical literature actually think about many connections.

The canonical example is PTSD to sleep apnea. A direct "PTSD causes OSA" argument is contested. But the intermediary pathway is far more defensible:

INTERMEDIARY PATHWAY — PTSD TO SLEEP APNEA PTSD service-connected MECHANISMS • disrupted / fragmented sleep • psychotropic medication effects • reduced activity / avoidance • stress-driven metabolic change OBESITY the intermediary step (weight gain) OSA DC 6847 Each link is individually defensible — and obesity is the single strongest, best-documented risk factor for OSA.

Figure: The intermediary-step pathway. Rather than asserting PTSD directly causes obstructive sleep apnea, a nexus opinion can build a chain in which each link is well supported: PTSD degrades sleep and promotes weight gain → weight gain produces obesity → obesity is a major, well-established risk factor for OSA. Under VA General Counsel Precedent Opinion VAOPGCPREC 1-2017 and Walsh v. Wilkie, 32 Vet. App. 300 (2020), obesity is not itself a disability but can be an “intermediate step”: VA must consider whether the service-connected disability caused or aggravated the obesity, whether the obesity was a substantial factor in causing the claimed condition, and whether that condition would not have occurred but for the obesity.

This "systems-thinking" approach applies well beyond PTSD. Orthopedic claims follow the same logic — a single injury sets off a chain reaction through the kinetic chain:

ORTHOPEDIC CHAIN REACTION KNEE INJURY service-connected ALTERED GAIT antalgic / favoring limp (the intermediary) ABNORMAL LOADING opposite knee · hip · low back bear the extra stress SECONDARY CONDITIONS contralateral arthritis · lumbar strain · radiculopathy Document the gait change in your medical records — it is the link the VA looks for.

Figure: The orthopedic chain reaction. A service-connected knee or ankle injury forces an antalgic (favoring) gait; that altered mechanics overloads the opposite knee, the hips, and the lumbar spine, which over time can produce contralateral joint arthritis and lumbar conditions — including radiculopathy. The intermediary that ties the chain together is the documented gait abnormality, so make sure it appears in your clinical notes.

💡

Name the Intermediary in Your Nexus Letter

When a relationship is weak as a direct one-step claim but strong as a chain, the winning move is to make the intermediary explicit. Have your physician write the opinion as a sequence — "the service-connected condition caused [intermediary], and [intermediary] is a well-established cause of [claimed condition]" — and document the intermediary (weight gain, altered gait, medication use) in your treatment records. A documented intermediary turns a contested claim into a defensible one.

Building Your Secondary Nexus Letter

The nexus opinion is the linchpin of every secondary claim. Sometimes a favorable C&P opinion does the job; when it does not, a private letter is what the rater weighs against the examiner’s opinion, and a well-reasoned private opinion from a relevant specialist can outweigh a cursory C&P opinion (see the nexus-letter checklist to decide whether you need one). For a secondary claim, the letter must connect the new condition to the primary service-connected condition — not to service.

A Strong Secondary Nexus Letter Includes:

  • The exact phrase: "at least as likely as not" caused or aggravated by
  • The name of the primary service-connected condition (with its diagnostic code/rating)
  • The current diagnosis of the secondary condition
  • The specific medical mechanism — and any intermediary step — explained, not just asserted
  • Citation of supporting peer-reviewed medical literature
  • Confirmation the physician reviewed the veteran's records
  • The physician's credentials and relevant specialty
  • Ideally written by the treating specialist

A Weak Nexus Letter Will Fail:

  • "Possibly related," "may be related," or "could be associated" — legally insufficient
  • A conclusion with no explanation of the mechanism
  • Written by a physician in an unrelated specialty
  • Does not name the primary service-connected condition
  • Not based on a review of the veteran's records
  • Asserts a coincidence ("I have both") rather than a pathway
  • For aggravation claims: fails to address the baseline at all

Model Nexus Language — Secondary (Causation)

Have your treating specialist adapt this to your facts. The mechanism paragraph should reflect your actual clinical picture:

"It is my medical opinion that it is at least as likely as not (50% or greater probability) that [Veteran's Name]'s current diagnosis of [secondary condition] is caused by his/her service-connected [primary condition, rated __% under Diagnostic Code ____].

The mechanism is as follows: [explain how the primary condition produces the secondary — include any intermediary step, e.g., "the service-connected PTSD has driven significant weight gain and obesity, and obesity is a major, well-established risk factor for obstructive sleep apnea"]. This pathway is supported by [cite literature].

This opinion is based on my examination and treatment of the veteran, my review of his/her VA and private medical records, and my [X] years of experience as a board-certified [specialty]."

Model Nexus Language — Secondary (Aggravation)

"It is my medical opinion that it is at least as likely as not that [Veteran's Name]'s [pre-existing condition] has been aggravated by his/her service-connected [primary condition] — that is, it is more severe than it would be without the service-connected condition. Before the aggravation, the baseline severity was [describe, with reference to the earliest records]; the condition has since worsened to [current severity]. The increase is attributable to the service-connected condition because [mechanism — including, if applicable, how the service-connected condition has interfered with treatment of this condition]."

Note: the opinion does not need to say the aggravation is "permanent." Under Ward v. Wilkie, any increase in severity counts for § 3.310(b). And under El-Amin v. Shinseki, a VA opinion that addresses only causation, and not aggravation, is inadequate. If a C&P opinion denies aggravation only because the worsening was not "permanent," that opinion applied the wrong standard.

How Secondary Ratings Combine

A secondary condition receives its own diagnostic code and its own percentage. That percentage then combines with your other ratings under the VA's whole-person formula — it does not simply add. Because of how the formula works, adding a secondary condition at the right percentage can push you across an important threshold (for example, from 80% to 90%, or to the 100% schedular level, or into TDIU eligibility).

Run your real numbers on the Combined Ratings Calculator before and after a prospective secondary, so you understand exactly what a grant would be worth. For aggravation grants, remember the rating reflects only the increment above your established baseline — which is one more reason to scrutinize the baseline the VA assigns.

Common Secondary Denials and How to Respond

Denial: "No Nexus Between the Secondary and Primary Condition"

The most common — and most fixable — secondary denial. The C&P examiner opined that the link is "less likely than not," or that it "cannot be established without resort to speculation." First check whether the opinion is inadequate on its face — it ignored your lay evidence, applied the wrong standard, or gave no rationale. If so, a Higher-Level Review can raise that error without new evidence, and VA may have to obtain a new opinion. If the real gap is that no favorable medical opinion exists, counter with a private nexus letter from a treating specialist that (1) reaches "at least as likely as not," (2) explains the mechanism (and any intermediary) in detail, and (3) cites supporting literature. File a Supplemental Claim (VA Form 20-0995) with that letter as new and relevant evidence. Under 38 CFR § 3.102, if the opinions are in equipoise the benefit of the doubt goes to the veteran.

Denial: "The Secondary Condition Pre-Existed and Is Not Related"

If the condition genuinely pre-existed, you may be in aggravation territory rather than causation. Re-file (or appeal) on the § 3.310(b) aggravation theory, with an opinion that establishes the pre-aggravation baseline and explains how the service-connected condition made it worse. A denial of causation is not a denial of aggravation — they are separate theories.

Denial: "Not Permanently Aggravated" or "Due to Natural Progression"

If the examiner or rater denied aggravation because the worsening was "temporary," "not permanent," or "not beyond natural progression," point out the error. Ward v. Wilkie, 31 Vet. App. 233 (2019), holds that § 3.310(b) aggravation need not be permanent, and VA's M21-1 (V.ii.2.D), following Spicer v. McDonough, tells raters to apply a but-for standard without deducting natural progress. An opinion built on the wrong legal standard is inadequate. Because this is a legal error in how existing evidence was weighed, a Higher-Level Review is often the right lane — no new evidence required. If the real problem is that no opinion addressed aggravation at all, VA's duty to assist may require a new opinion.

Denial: Aggravation Granted, but the Baseline Is Too High

When the VA grants aggravation it must establish a baseline and pay only the increase above it. If the assigned baseline is higher than the medical record supports, your compensation is understated. Challenge the baseline in a Higher-Level Review or Supplemental Claim, pointing to the earliest medical evidence of the condition's true (lower) baseline severity.

Denial: "Claim Decided Without a C&P Examination"

Under McLendon v. Nicholson, 20 Vet. App. 79 (2006), the VA must provide an exam when there is a current disability, an established service-connected primary, an indication of a possible link, and not enough medical evidence to decide the claim — a low threshold implementing 38 CFR § 3.159(c)(4). Deciding a secondary claim with no exam at all is a failure of the duty to assist under § 3.159 — raise it in a Higher-Level Review.

⚠️

Appeal Within One Year — Every Time

You have one year from the date on your rating decision to appeal without losing your effective date. After any denial, evaluate your lanes promptly: a Supplemental Claim (best with new evidence such as a nexus letter), a Higher-Level Review (best for a clear factual or legal error), or a Board appeal. A VSO can help you choose — that help is always free. Full detail is on the Appeals page.

Key Regulations & Case Law to Cite in Secondary Claims

Citing the governing authorities signals to the rater that you understand the framework — and makes it harder for the VA to misapply the law:

💡

Related Resources on This Site

Build on this guide with: The Caluza Triangle for the service-connection foundation, CFR & M21-1 Regulations for the full regulatory text, Case Law for the controlling precedent, DBQs for the form your specialist should complete, Building a Strong Claim for overall evidence strategy, and the PACT Act guide for secondary claims built on a presumptive primary. If your claim is denied, see the Appeals guide.

A note on the medical references above: the cited studies and guidelines are provided for education and to help you and your physician identify the literature relevant to your situation. They are not a substitute for an individualized medical opinion. Whether any relationship applies in your case is a clinical question for a licensed provider who has examined you and reviewed your records.