Find the Rule You Need

Start with your problem or with a regulation number. Every entry below follows the same order, so once you have read one you know where to look in all of them.

Browse by problem Help me find the right rule Pick the situation you are dealing with and go straight to the regulation that governs it. Numerical index I know the regulation number Every section on this page, in numerical order, with a one-line description.

Starting a Claim & Gathering Evidence

Connecting a Disability to Service

C&P Exams & Medical Reports

Understanding Your Percentage

Denials, Reviews & Appeals

Effective Dates & Back Pay

Protecting Ratings & Additional Benefits

VA Health Care

Not sure whether 38 CFR or the VA’s manual controls? See 38 CFR vs. M21-1: what’s the difference. Looking for the manual procedure behind a regulation? Use the M21-1 Manual Index.

38 CFR Part 3 — Adjudication (claims, service connection, effective dates, reviews)

38 CFR Part 4 — Schedule for Rating Disabilities

38 CFR Part 17 — Medical (VA health care)

38 CFR Part 20 — Board of Veterans’ Appeals

Section numbers are the official 38 CFR citations. The topic sections below are reading groups for this page; they do not change which CFR Part a rule belongs to.

How every entry is organized
  1. The question it answers
  2. Regulation number & title
  3. In plain English
  4. When it matters & important limits
  5. Examples & practical guides
  6. Related court decisions
  7. VA manual procedure
  8. Official regulation

Starting a Claim & Gathering Evidence

How a claim begins, how to protect your start date while you gather evidence, what VA must do to help you build the record, and the fair-process rights that apply throughout.

Also relevant: § 3.160 — whether an earlier claim is still pending

Filing & Effective Dates

The question it answersHow do I start a claim, and lock in my effective date before my evidence is ready?

38 CFR § 3.155 — How to File a Claim & Intent to File

In plain English
Sets out how a claim is started and filed. The most valuable part is § 3.155(b), the Intent to File: a short notice — online, on VA Form 21-0966, or by phone with VA — that tells the VA you plan to file. If you then submit a complete claim within one year, the VA treats it as filed on the date it received your Intent to File, which can add months of back pay.
When it matters & important limits
The printed regulation still says the Intent-to-File rule does not apply to Supplemental Claims, but that exclusion is no longer enforced: the Federal Circuit invalidated it in Military-Veterans Advocacy v. Secretary of Veterans Affairs, 7 F.4th 1110 (Fed. Cir. 2021). VA's current guidance lets an Intent to File apply to a claim or a Supplemental Claim for compensation, pension or DIC. Under the M21-1, it applies to a qualifying Supplemental Claim that was not finally adjudicated on or after July 30, 2021. It does not apply to Higher-Level Review.
Related court decisions
Military-Veterans Advocacy v. Secretary of Veterans Affairs, 7 F.4th 1110 (Fed. Cir. 2021), described above. Browse the Case Law Reference →
Official regulation
38 CFR § 3.155 on eCFR ↗
VA Obligations

The question it answersDid VA do enough to get my records and give me an exam?

38 CFR § 3.159 — VA's Duty to Assist

In plain English
The VA is legally required to assist veterans in developing their claims. This includes obtaining relevant records, providing C&P exams when warranted, and notifying veterans of what evidence is needed.
When it matters & important limits
When the VA fails to fulfill its duty to assist — by not obtaining records it knew existed, or by not ordering a required exam — that failure is a procedural error that can be raised in an appeal. This regulation is the basis for challenging inadequate C&P exams.
Official regulation
38 CFR § 3.159 on eCFR ↗
Evidence Standard

The question it answersWho wins when the evidence for and against my claim is close?

38 CFR § 3.102 — Benefit of the Doubt

In plain English
The single most important regulation for veterans. Requires the VA to resolve reasonable doubt in the veteran's favor when evidence is in approximate balance. You do not need to prove your claim beyond a reasonable doubt — you need to get to roughly 50/50.
When it matters & important limits
The evidence does not have to be an exact tie; if it is nearly equal, VA must find in your favor (Lynch v. McDonough). Cite this in every appeal where evidence is contested.
VA manual procedure
M21-1 V.ii.1.A →
Official regulation
38 CFR § 3.102 on eCFR ↗
Due Process

The question it answersWhat fair-process rights do I have: notice, a hearing, representation?

38 CFR § 3.103 — VA Claimants' Due Process Rights

In plain English
An underrated but powerful regulation. It guarantees veterans a set of fair-process rights throughout the claims process: the right to notice of decisions and of the evidence needed, the right to a hearing, and the right to representation.
When it matters & important limits
When the VA decides a claim without proper notice, denies a requested hearing, or otherwise short-circuits fair process, § 3.103 is the regulation that was violated. These procedural arguments come up constantly in appeals and can require the VA to redo a decision regardless of the underlying medical evidence.
Examples & practical guides
Related court decisions
None collected on this site for this rule. Browse the Case Law Reference →
VA manual procedure
M21-1 I.i.1.B, X.ii.3.A →
Official regulation
38 CFR § 3.103 on eCFR ↗

↑ Back to the finder

Connecting a Disability to Service

The routes to service connection: direct, secondary, presumptive and aggravation, plus the special rules for PTSD, hearing loss, tobacco, Gulf War illness and burn pit exposure.

Also relevant: § 3.102 — benefit of the doubt on a contested nexus · § 4.2 — when a nexus exam is inadequate

Service Connection

The question it answersHow do I prove a condition started in, or was caused by, my service?

38 CFR § 3.303 — Direct Service Connection

In plain English
Establishes how service connection is proven for conditions that began in or were caused by military service. Section 3.303(a) covers a disease or injury incurred in service; § 3.303(b) covers chronic diseases shown in service and continuity of symptomatology, a route the Federal Circuit has limited to the chronic diseases listed in § 3.309(a) (Walker v. Shinseki); and § 3.303(d) allows service connection for a disease first diagnosed after discharge when the evidence shows it was incurred in service. (Aggravation of a condition that existed before service is covered by § 3.306.)
When it matters & important limits
Every direct claim comes down to the three elements in Shedden v. Principi: a current disability, an in-service disease or injury, and a nexus between them. A diagnosis made shortly before you filed can satisfy the first element (Romanowsky v. Shinseki). The presumption of soundness and the combat-veteran rule are in § 3.304.
VA manual procedure
M21-1 V.ii.2.A →
Official regulation
38 CFR § 3.303 on eCFR ↗
Service Connection

The question it answersVA says my condition existed before service, or there’s no record of my combat injury. Now what?

38 CFR § 3.304 — Direct Service Connection: Presumption of Soundness & Combat Veterans

In plain English
The companion to § 3.303 with two rules that often decide a claim. Under the presumption of soundness in § 3.304(b), you are presumed to have been in sound condition when you entered service, except for defects, infirmities or disorders noted on your entrance exam. To overcome that presumption, VA needs clear and unmistakable evidence that the condition existed before service and clear and unmistakable evidence that service did not aggravate it.
When it matters & important limits
A condition the VA calls “pre-existing” that was never noted at entry is not automatically excluded. Under § 3.304(d), which carries out 38 U.S.C. § 1154(b), a veteran who engaged in combat can establish an injury or disease in service with satisfactory lay evidence that is consistent with the circumstances of that service, even if there is no official record of it. You still need a current disability and a nexus. The PTSD rules in the same section are covered separately under § 3.304(f).
Related court decisions
Buchanan v. Nicholson (2006)
Official regulation
38 CFR § 3.304 on eCFR ↗
Service Connection — PTSD

The question it answersWhat evidence does VA need to confirm a PTSD stressor, including MST?

38 CFR § 3.304(f) — PTSD Service Connection

In plain English
Specifically governs service connection for PTSD. This subsection was significantly liberalized in 2010 — for stressors based on fear of hostile military or terrorist activity, your own testimony can establish the stressor without independent corroboration if a VA or VA-contracted psychiatrist or psychologist confirms it supports the PTSD diagnosis and it is consistent with the places, types, and circumstances of your service (§ 3.304(f)(3)). For MST and other personal-assault claims, the stressor may be corroborated by evidence other than service records — such as behavioral changes after the event — and VA must tell you about those options before denying the claim (§ 3.304(f)(5); Patton v. West). A medical opinion can help corroborate the stressor (Menegassi v. Shinseki).
When it matters & important limits
If your PTSD claim was denied before 2010, the regulatory change may be grounds for a new claim with a more favorable standard applied.
Official regulation
38 CFR § 3.304 on eCFR ↗ (paragraph (f) is the PTSD rule)
Service Connection — Aggravation

The question it answersA condition I had before service got worse during service. Can it be service connected?

38 CFR § 3.306 — Aggravation of a Pre-Service Condition

In plain English
Covers conditions you had before you entered service that got worse during it. If the disability increased in severity during service, it is presumed to have been aggravated by service unless the VA makes a specific finding that the increase was due to the natural progress of the condition — and for wartime service and peacetime service after December 31, 1946, rebutting that presumption takes clear and unmistakable evidence.
When it matters & important limits
If the condition did not worsen during service at all, aggravation cannot be conceded. Do not confuse this with § 3.310(b), which covers a non-service-connected condition worsened after service by a service-connected one.
Related court decisions
None collected on this site for this rule. Browse the Case Law Reference →
VA manual procedure
M21-1 V.ii.2.C →
Official regulation
38 CFR § 3.306 on eCFR ↗
Presumptive Service Connection

The question it answersHow soon after service must a presumptive condition show up, and who is presumed exposed to Agent Orange?

38 CFR § 3.307 — Presumptive Periods: Chronic Diseases & Herbicide Exposure

In plain English
Sets the conditions a presumptive claim under § 3.309 must meet. For the chronic diseases in § 3.309(a), you generally need 90 days or more of continuous active service, and the disease must appear to a degree of 10 percent or more within one year after separation. The window is longer for a few diseases: three years for tuberculosis and Hansen’s disease, and seven years for multiple sclerosis. For herbicide (Agent Orange) exposure, § 3.307(a)(6) defines who is presumed exposed, starting with service in the Republic of Vietnam between January 9, 1962 and May 7, 1975, and most § 3.309(e) diseases can appear at any time after service.
When it matters & important limits
Chloracne, porphyria cutanea tarda and early-onset peripheral neuropathy are the exceptions: they must appear to a degree of 10 percent or more within one year of last exposure. Section 3.307(d) also explains when VA can rebut a presumption with affirmative evidence.
Related court decisions
None collected on this site for this rule. Browse the Case Law Reference →
Official regulation
38 CFR § 3.307 on eCFR ↗
Presumptive Service Connection

The question it answersIs my condition on a presumptive list, so I may not need a nexus opinion?

38 CFR § 3.309 — Diseases Subject to Presumptive Service Connection

In plain English
The master list of presumptive diseases. Paragraph (a) lists the "chronic diseases" — arthritis, hypertension (as cardiovascular-renal disease), organic diseases of the nervous system, and others — that are presumed service connected if they appear to a compensable degree within the time limit in § 3.307 after qualifying service. It is also the list that controls the continuity-of-symptomatology route under § 3.303(b). Later paragraphs cover diseases presumed for former POWs, radiation-exposed veterans, and herbicide (Agent Orange) exposure under § 3.309(e).
When it matters & important limits
If your condition is on one of these lists, you may not need a nexus opinion at all.
Related court decisions
None collected on this site for this rule. Browse the Case Law Reference →
Official regulation
38 CFR § 3.309 on eCFR ↗
Service Connection — Secondary

The question it answersCan I get service connection for a condition caused or worsened by one I’m already rated for?

38 CFR § 3.310 — Secondary Service Connection & Aggravation

In plain English
Governs service connection for conditions caused or aggravated by an already service-connected disability. This is the regulatory basis for secondary claims — a service-connected knee causing hip problems, PTSD causing depression, chronic pain causing GI conditions. Under this regulation, aggravation of a non-service-connected condition by a service-connected one is also compensable, even if the original condition predated service.
When it matters & important limits
The aggravation does not have to be permanent — any increase in severity counts (Ward v. Wilkie, 2019) — but VA must be able to establish a baseline and compensates only the increase above it.
VA manual procedure
M21-1 V.ii.2.D →
Official regulation
38 CFR § 3.310 on eCFR ↗
Service Connection — Tobacco

The question it answersCan I service-connect a condition related to smoking or tobacco use?

38 CFR § 3.300 — Claims Based on the Effects of Tobacco Products

In plain English
Implements 38 U.S.C. § 1103. For claims received after June 9, 1998, VA will not service-connect a disability or death on the basis that it resulted from tobacco use during service (§ 3.300(a)).
When it matters & important limits
The bar does not apply if the condition is service-connected on some other basis, became evident during service, or appeared within a presumptive period under § 3.307 and § 3.309 (§ 3.300(b)). Under § 3.300(c), VA will not use § 3.310(a) to secondarily service-connect a condition caused by a disability that was itself service-connected because of in-service tobacco use. The bar does not stop a claim where a service-connected condition, such as PTSD, caused you to use tobacco after service and that tobacco use caused a new disability (VA General Counsel Precedent Opinion VAOPGCPREC 6-2003).
Related court decisions
None collected on this site. The key interpretation is a VA General Counsel opinion, VAOPGCPREC 6-2003, described above. See OGC Precedent Opinions ↗
VA manual procedure
No M21-1 section is matched to this rule in our index. Browse the M21-1 Manual Index →
Official regulation
38 CFR § 3.300 on eCFR ↗
Service Connection — Hearing

The question it answersWhy did VA say my hearing loss isn’t a “disability”?

38 CFR § 3.385 — When Hearing Loss Counts as a Disability

In plain English
Hearing loss is not a “disability” for VA purposes until it crosses a specific line on a hearing test. Under § 3.385, impaired hearing is a disability when the auditory threshold at any of 500, 1000, 2000, 3000 or 4000 Hz is 40 decibels or greater; when at least three of those frequencies have thresholds of 26 decibels or greater; or when the speech recognition score on the Maryland CNC test is less than 94 percent.
When it matters & important limits
If your test does not meet this definition, the claim fails on the current-disability element even if your hearing is worse than when you entered service. Hearing that was normal at separation does not by itself defeat a claim if the loss now meets § 3.385 and a nexus to in-service noise is shown. The examiner must also describe the functional effects of your hearing loss, not just the test scores (Martinak v. Nicholson). Tinnitus is a separate condition with no test threshold, and you are competent to describe it yourself (Charles v. Principi).
VA manual procedure
M21-1 V.iii.2.B →
Official regulation
38 CFR § 3.385 on eCFR ↗
Presumptive — Gulf War

The question it answersI served in the Gulf and have symptoms no one can diagnose. Is there a presumption?

38 CFR § 3.317 — Persian Gulf Veterans: Undiagnosed & Multisymptom Illnesses

In plain English
Allows compensation for Persian Gulf veterans with objective signs of a chronic disability that either cannot be attributed to any known clinical diagnosis (an "undiagnosed illness") or is a medically unexplained chronic multisymptom illness such as chronic fatigue syndrome, fibromyalgia, or a functional gastrointestinal disorder.
When it matters & important limits
Section 405 of the PACT Act (Pub. L. 117-168, 2022) amended 38 U.S.C. § 1117 so that a qualifying chronic disability counts if it became manifest to any degree at any time. There is no longer a date by which it must appear and no 10 percent minimum. Section 405 also added Afghanistan, Israel, Egypt, Turkey, Syria, and Jordan to the places that make someone a Persian Gulf veteran.The text of § 3.317 still says the disability must have appeared during service in the Southwest Asia theater of operations or to a degree of 10 percent or more by December 31, 2026, because VA has not finalized its update. VA proposed removing that date in the Federal Register on October 1, 2024 (89 FR 79815). Where the regulation and the statute differ, the statute controls.It also covers certain infectious diseases tied to that service. These claims do not require you to prove what caused the illness.
Related court decisions
None collected on this site for this rule. Browse the Case Law Reference →
Presumptive — Burn Pits & PACT Act

The question it answersIs my respiratory condition or cancer presumed to come from burn pits or other airborne hazards?

38 CFR §§ 3.320–3.320b — Burn Pit & Airborne Hazard Presumptives

In plain English
The regulations that implement the burn pit and airborne hazard presumptives. § 3.320 covers claims based on exposure to fine particulate matter: asthma, rhinitis, and sinusitis (including rhinosinusitis), plus a list of rare respiratory cancers, are service connected for veterans with qualifying service if they appear to any degree after separation. § 3.320a adds bladder, ureter, and related genitourinary cancers, and § 3.320b adds leukemias, multiple myelomas (including MGUS), myelodysplastic syndromes, and myelofibrosis.
When it matters & important limits
Under these rules, exposure is presumed for covered veterans unless there is affirmative evidence they were not exposed.
Related court decisions
None collected on this site for this rule. Browse the Case Law Reference →

↑ Back to the finder

C&P Exams & Medical Reports

When VA must examine you, when your own doctor’s report can carry the claim, what makes an exam inadequate, reexaminations, and what happens if you miss one.

Also relevant: § 3.159(c)(4) — when VA must provide an exam · § 4.59 — what a joint exam must test · §§ 4.40 & 4.45 — functional loss and flare-ups

Examinations

The question it answersWhen can VA rate my claim on my own doctor’s report or a private DBQ instead of its own exam?

38 CFR § 3.326 — Examinations & Private Medical Reports

In plain English
Covers when VA orders its own exam and when it can rate a claim on evidence you send in. Under § 3.326(a), VA will schedule an exam when the medical evidence with a compensation or pension claim is not adequate for rating purposes, and anyone scheduled for an exam is required to report. Under § 3.326(b) and (c), a hospital or exam report from a government or private institution, or a statement from a private physician, may be accepted for rating without a further VA exam if it is otherwise adequate.
When it matters & important limits
That is why a thorough private DBQ can carry a claim on its own. VA’s duty to provide an exam when one is needed comes from § 3.159(c)(4), and what counts as an adequate report is in § 4.2.
VA manual procedure
No M21-1 section is matched to this rule in our index. Browse the M21-1 Manual Index →
Official regulation
38 CFR § 3.326 on eCFR ↗
Exam Adequacy

The question it answersCan a thin, incomplete or wrong C&P exam be used to rate me?

38 CFR § 4.2 — Interpretation of Examination Reports

In plain English
Requires the rater to read each examination report in light of your whole recorded history and reconcile the reports into a consistent picture, considering each disability from the point of view of a veteran working or seeking work.
When it matters & important limits
Most useful in an appeal: if a diagnosis is not supported by the findings, or the report does not contain enough detail, the rating board is required to return it as inadequate for rating purposes. This is the regulation behind the argument that a thin or incomplete C&P exam cannot support a rating.
VA manual procedure
M21-1 IV.i.3.A, IV.i.3.C →
Official regulation
38 CFR § 4.2 on eCFR ↗
Examinations

The question it answersWhen will VA reexamine a rating I already have, and can I ask for a new exam if I’ve gotten worse?

38 CFR § 3.327 — Reexaminations

In plain English
Governs when the VA asks for a new examination of a disability that is already rated. Under § 3.327(a), reexamination is generally required when it is likely a disability has improved, or when evidence indicates a material change in the disability or that the current rating may be incorrect.
When it matters & important limits
The same rule works for you: if your condition has worsened, evidence of that change is what supports a request for an updated exam. Paragraph (b) also lists situations where routine future exams are generally not scheduled, such as static disabilities.
VA manual procedure
M21-1 IV.ii.1.A →
Official regulation
38 CFR § 3.327 on eCFR ↗
Examinations

The question it answersWhat happens if I miss a C&P exam or reexamination?

38 CFR § 3.655 — Failure to Report for a VA Examination

In plain English
Spells out what happens when you miss a VA exam without good cause. Good cause includes your own illness or hospitalization or the death of an immediate family member (§ 3.655(a)). Under § 3.655(b), if the exam was for an original compensation claim, the claim is rated on the evidence already in the file; if it was for any other original claim, a supplemental claim for a previously denied benefit, or a claim for an increase, the claim is denied.
When it matters & important limits
If you miss a reexamination of a rating you already have (§ 3.327), § 3.655(c) starts a separate process: VA sends a notice proposing to stop or reduce payments, and you have 60 days to say you are willing to report or to send evidence. If you say you will report and then miss the rescheduled exam, payment is reduced or stopped until an exam is done. If you cannot make an appointment, contact VA or the exam contractor before the date to reschedule.
Related court decisions
None collected on this site for this rule. Browse the Case Law Reference →
VA manual procedure
No M21-1 section is matched to this rule in our index. Browse the M21-1 Manual Index →
Official regulation
38 CFR § 3.655 on eCFR ↗

↑ Back to the finder

Understanding Your Percentage

How a percentage is chosen: the rating criteria for common conditions, doubt about severity, functional loss, pyramiding, combined ratings and the bilateral factor.

Also relevant: § 4.16 — TDIU when you cannot work · § 3.350 — Special Monthly Compensation

Evidence Standard

The question it answersWho gets the benefit of the doubt about how severe my condition is?

38 CFR § 4.3 — Reasonable Doubt in Disability Ratings

In plain English
Part 4's own benefit-of-the-doubt provision, and the companion to § 3.102. It requires the rater to resolve reasonable doubt about the degree of disability in the veteran's favor. Reasonable doubt is not speculative possibility — it exists when the evidence for and against a point is in approximate balance.
When it matters & important limits
In practice: conflicting range-of-motion findings, an exam that captured a good day, a symptom the examiner recorded as unclear. Where the record is genuinely equivocal about how severe a condition is, the doubt goes to the veteran. § 4.3 is about who wins a tie on the evidence. It is not the rule for deciding which of two rating levels your symptoms fall under — that is § 4.7. The two are often cited together, and they should be, but they do different work. Confusing them weakens an otherwise good argument.
Examples & practical guides
VA manual procedure
M21-1 V.ii.3.D, V.ii.1.A →
Official regulation
38 CFR § 4.3 on eCFR ↗
Choosing a Rating Level

The question it answersMy symptoms fall between two percentages. Which one should I get?

38 CFR § 4.7 — Higher of Two Disability Evaluations

In plain English
The rule for choosing between two rating levels. When the disability picture more nearly approximates the criteria for the higher rating than the lower one, the higher evaluation must be assigned.
When it matters & important limits
Veterans frequently assume they must satisfy every single symptom listed at a rating level to earn it — § 4.7 makes clear they do not. What matters is which level the overall picture most closely resembles. This is especially powerful in mental health claims, where the criteria are descriptive rather than a strict checklist. Where § 4.3 resolves doubt about what the evidence shows, § 4.7 decides which set of criteria the established picture more nearly matches. Cite § 4.7 when your symptoms clearly lean toward the higher rating but the VA assigned the lower one.
Examples & practical guides
Related court decisions
None collected on this site for this rule. Browse the Case Law Reference →
VA manual procedure
M21-1 V.ii.3.D, V.ii.1.A →
Official regulation
38 CFR § 4.7 on eCFR ↗
Choosing a Rating Level

The question it answersDo I need every listed symptom to qualify for a rating level?

38 CFR § 4.21 — Rating Based on Actual Functional Impairment

In plain English
Establishes that it is not expected, especially with the more fully described grades of disability, that all cases will show all the findings specified for a rating level. The rating is meant to track the actual impairment of function — not a literal checklist of every listed symptom.
When it matters & important limits
This regulation is invaluable for mental health, migraine, and other functional-impairment claims, where veterans are often told they "don't meet" a level because they lack one or two listed symptoms. Read together with § 4.7, it explains why the overall functional picture controls the rating.
Related court decisions
Mauerhan v. Principi (2002)
VA manual procedure
M21-1 V.ii.3.D, V.ii.1.A →
Official regulation
38 CFR § 4.21 on eCFR ↗
Mental Health

The question it answersWhat happens if my mental health diagnosis does not fit the DSM-5, or changes over time?

38 CFR § 4.125 — Diagnosis of Mental Disorders

In plain English
A mental disorder diagnosis must conform to the DSM-5 (the American Psychiatric Association’s Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fifth Edition) and be supported by the findings in the exam report. If it is not, VA must return the report to the examiner to substantiate the diagnosis (§ 4.125(a)).
When it matters & important limits
When your diagnosis changes, VA must decide whether the new diagnosis is a progression of the earlier one, a correction of an error in it, or a new and separate condition. If the records do not make that clear, VA must return the report to the examiner for a determination (§ 4.125(b)).This section governs the diagnosis, not the percentage. The rating itself comes from the general rating formula in § 4.130, applied under § 4.126.
Related court decisions
Clemons v. Shinseki (2009)
VA manual procedure
M21-1 V.iii.13 →
Official regulation
38 CFR § 4.125 on eCFR ↗
Mental Health

The question it answersHow is my PTSD, depression or anxiety percentage decided?

38 CFR § 4.130 — Mental Health Rating Criteria

In plain English
The rating schedule governing all mental health conditions — PTSD, depression, anxiety, and others. Ratings run from 0% to 100% based on occupational and social impairment. The 10% level covers mild or transient symptoms that reduce work efficiency only during periods of significant stress, or symptoms controlled by continuous medication.
When it matters & important limits
Understanding the specific criteria at each level (10%, 30%, 50%, 70%, 100%) and mapping your documented symptoms to the correct level is essential for any mental health claim or increase. Many veterans are rated at 30 or 50% when their documented symptoms place them at 70%.Proposed changes pending: VA has proposed replacing this formula with new mental disorder criteria and has told Congress it expects to finalize the remaining rating-schedule updates, including mental disorders, by the end of fiscal year 2026. Until a final rule is published, the criteria above apply. Check the eCFR link below for the version currently in effect.
VA manual procedure
M21-1 V.iii.13 →
Official regulation
38 CFR § 4.130 on eCFR ↗
Mental Health

The question it answersBeyond the exam-day snapshot, what must VA weigh when rating a mental health condition?

38 CFR § 4.126 — Evaluation of Disability From Mental Disorders

In plain English
The instructions that sit on top of the § 4.130 rating formula. The VA must consider the frequency, severity, and duration of psychiatric symptoms, the length of remissions, and your capacity to adjust during remissions — and base the rating on all the evidence of occupational and social impairment, not only the examiner’s snapshot on the day of the exam.
When it matters & important limits
Social impairment is considered but cannot be the sole basis of the rating. When one disability is diagnosed as both a physical and a mental condition, it is rated under the code for whichever aspect is more disabling.
Related court decisions
None collected on this site for this rule. Browse the Case Law Reference →
VA manual procedure
M21-1 V.iii.13 →
Official regulation
38 CFR § 4.126 on eCFR ↗
Pyramiding

The question it answersWhy do my several mental health diagnoses get only one rating, and when are separate ratings allowed?

38 CFR § 4.14 — Avoidance of Pyramiding

In plain English
The anti-pyramiding rule. The same disability, or the same symptom, should not be rated under more than one diagnosis. That is why PTSD, depression, and anxiety receive one combined mental health rating instead of three.
When it matters & important limits
The rule is about overlapping manifestations, not diagnoses: a distinct physical condition secondary to a mental health condition — sleep apnea, migraines, hypertension — involves different symptoms and is rated separately. The CAVC drew that line in Esteban v. Brown: separate ratings are allowed when none of the symptoms of one condition duplicate or overlap the symptoms of another. Knowing where that line falls keeps you from expecting extra percentages the VA cannot award, and from giving up separate ratings you are entitled to.
Related court decisions
Esteban v. Brown (1994)
VA manual procedure
M21-1 V.ii.3.D →
Official regulation
38 CFR § 4.14 on eCFR ↗
Musculoskeletal

The question it answersMy back, knee or shoulder pain limits me more than my range of motion shows. Does that count?

38 CFR §§ 4.40 & 4.45 — Functional Loss, Pain & Musculoskeletal Ratings

In plain English
These regulations require the VA to rate musculoskeletal disabilities based on functional loss — not just range of motion measurements. Pain, weakness, fatigability, and incoordination that limit function must be considered in the rating, even when range of motion itself is not dramatically reduced.
When it matters & important limits
Pain by itself is not functional loss, though: it has to actually limit how the joint works, such as its range, strength, speed, coordination or endurance (Mitchell v. Shinseki). These regulations, combined with DeLuca v. Brown, are the basis for arguing that a back or knee rating is too low even when the goniometer measurements alone do not support a higher rating.
VA manual procedure
M21-1 V.iii.1.A →
Musculoskeletal

The question it answersDid my joint exam test what it was supposed to test?

38 CFR § 4.59 — Painful Motion

In plain English
Recognizes painful motion as a disabling factor. Its stated intent is that actually painful, unstable, or malaligned joints due to healed injury are entitled to at least the minimum compensable rating for the joint.
When it matters & important limits
Its final sentence is the one examiners most often skip: joints should be tested for pain on both active and passive motion, in weight-bearing and non-weight-bearing, and, if possible, compared with the opposite undamaged joint. The CAVC enforced that testing requirement in Correia v. McDonald. The rule is not limited to arthritis (Burton v. Shinseki), and painful motion can earn the minimum compensable rating for the joint under the applicable diagnostic code even without X-ray evidence of arthritis (Petitti v. McDonald).
VA manual procedure
M21-1 V.iii.1.A →
Official regulation
38 CFR § 4.59 on eCFR ↗
Rating Schedule — Musculoskeletal

The question it answersHow is my back or joint percentage set?

38 CFR § 4.71a — Musculoskeletal Rating Schedule (Spine & Joints)

In plain English
The diagnostic codes for bones, joints and the spine. Most back conditions (DCs 5235–5243) are rated under the General Rating Formula for Diseases and Injuries of the Spine, which turns mainly on forward flexion and combined range of motion. For the thoracolumbar spine, 10 percent applies to forward flexion greater than 60 but not greater than 85 degrees, 20 percent to forward flexion greater than 30 but not greater than 60 degrees, and 40 percent to forward flexion of 30 degrees or less or favorable ankylosis. Intervertebral disc syndrome can instead be rated on incapacitating episodes, whichever is higher. Knees, shoulders, hips and other joints are rated on limitation of motion, instability or other specific findings.
When it matters & important limits
Associated nerve problems such as radiculopathy are rated separately under § 4.124a. Range-of-motion numbers are only half the picture: pain, flare-ups and functional loss under §§ 4.40, 4.45 and § 4.59 must be factored in.
Official regulation
38 CFR § 4.71a on eCFR ↗
Hearing & Ear

The question it answersHow does VA turn my hearing test into a percentage, and how are tinnitus and other ear conditions rated?

38 CFR §§ 4.85, 4.86 & 4.87 — Rating Hearing Loss and Ear Conditions

In plain English
§ 4.85: the hearing exam must be done by a state-licensed audiologist, without hearing aids, and include a Maryland CNC speech discrimination test and a puretone test. The puretone threshold average is the sum of your thresholds at 1000, 2000, 3000 and 4000 Hertz divided by four. Table VI combines that average with your speech discrimination score to give each ear a Roman numeral from I to XI, and Table VII combines the two ears’ numerals into the percentage. Table VIa uses the average alone when the examiner certifies the speech test is not appropriate, or when § 4.86 applies.§ 4.86, exceptional patterns: if every one of the four frequencies is 55 decibels or more, or if the threshold is 30 decibels or less at 1000 Hertz and 70 decibels or more at 2000 Hertz, VA uses whichever table gives the higher numeral. In the second pattern, that numeral is raised one more step. Each ear is evaluated separately.§ 4.87, the ear schedule: recurrent tinnitus (DC 6260) is rated 10 percent, with a single rating whether you hear it in one ear, both ears or your head. It can be combined with a rating under another code, such as hearing loss (DC 6100), unless the tinnitus is what supports that other rating. The schedule also covers conditions such as peripheral vestibular disorders (DC 6204) and Meniere’s syndrome (DC 6205).
When it matters & important limits
The hearing loss percentage comes mechanically from the test scores and the tables, so a disputed rating usually turns on whether the exam was done correctly or whether § 4.86 should have been applied. If only one ear is service connected, the other ear is assigned numeral I, subject to § 3.383 (§ 4.85(f)). VA must also check whether deafness qualifies you for SMC under § 3.350 (§ 4.85(g)). Whether your hearing loss counts as a disability at all is decided under § 3.385.Objective tinnitus, a sound other people can hear that has a definable cause, is not rated under DC 6260. It is rated as part of the condition causing it.
VA manual procedure
M21-1 V.iii.2.B →
Rating Schedule — Respiratory

The question it answersHow are sleep apnea, sinusitis, rhinitis and asthma rated?

38 CFR § 4.97 — Respiratory System (Sleep Apnea, Sinusitis, Asthma, Rhinitis)

In plain English
The respiratory section of the rating schedule. It contains Diagnostic Code 6847 for sleep apnea syndromes — 0% when asymptomatic with documented sleep-disordered breathing, 30% for persistent daytime hypersomnolence, 50% when a breathing assistance device such as a CPAP is required, and 100% for chronic respiratory failure with carbon dioxide retention or cor pulmonale, or a tracheostomy. It also holds the General Rating Formula for Sinusitis (DCs 6510–6514), which turns on incapacitating and non-incapacitating episodes, as well as the codes for rhinitis and asthma that matter in PACT Act claims.
When it matters & important limits
It matters for any sleep apnea, sinusitis, rhinitis or asthma rating, including the respiratory conditions that come up in PACT Act claims. Check which diagnostic code VA used, then compare your records with that code’s criteria. For sleep apnea, the 50% level turns on whether a breathing assistance device such as a CPAP is required.Proposed changes pending: VA has proposed rewriting the respiratory and ear criteria, including rating sleep apnea by how well treatment works rather than by CPAP use alone and changing how tinnitus is rated. The federal rulemaking page still lists these as a proposed rule, and VA has told Congress it expects final rules by the end of fiscal year 2026. Until a final rule is published, the criteria above apply.
Related court decisions
None collected on this site for this rule. Browse the Case Law Reference →
VA manual procedure
M21-1 V.iii.4.A →
Official regulation
38 CFR § 4.97 on eCFR ↗
Rating Schedule — Skin & Scars

The question it answersHow are painful, unstable and disfiguring scars rated, and can one scar get more than one rating?

38 CFR § 4.118 — Skin (Scars, DCs 7800–7805)

In plain English
The skin section of the rating schedule. DC 7800 rates disfigurement of the head, face or neck; DCs 7801 and 7802 rate other scars by area; DC 7804 rates scars that are unstable or painful (10% for one or two, 20% for three or four, 30% for five or more); and DC 7805 sends any other disabling effect of a scar to the appropriate code. Under DC 7804, Note (1) defines an unstable scar as one with frequent loss of covering of skin over the scar, Note (2) adds 10 percent when one or more scars are both unstable and painful, and Note (3) allows a DC 7804 evaluation on top of a rating under DC 7800, 7801, 7802 or 7805.
When it matters & important limits
The regulation itself does not say pain must be objectively confirmed, but VA’s manual (M21-1 V.iii.10.3.b) tells raters not to assign a compensable painful-scar evaluation without an objective indication, such as the examiner marking the scar tender to palpation on the DBQ. Separate scar ratings are proper when each compensates a different effect; rating the same pain twice is pyramiding (§ 4.14).Proposed changes pending (status checked October 23, 2026): VA has proposed adding Note (4) to DC 7804: “Pain must be confirmed by objective evidence upon evaluation or demonstration” (RIN 2900-AS37, 90 FR 46542, September 29, 2025). The rule is still proposed, not final, and eCFR lists only Notes (1) through (3). VA describes the note as a clarification of longstanding policy. Until a final rule is published, the criteria above apply.
Related court decisions
Esteban v. Brown (1994)
VA manual procedure
M21-1 V.iii.10 →
Rating Schedule — Neurological

The question it answersHow are migraines and nerve conditions like radiculopathy rated?

38 CFR § 4.124a — Neurological Conditions (Migraines, Nerves, Parkinson’s)

In plain English
The neurological section of the rating schedule. Diagnostic Code 8100 rates migraines by how often "characteristic prostrating attacks" occur: 10% for about one every two months, 30% for about one a month, and 50% for very frequent, completely prostrating, and prolonged attacks productive of severe economic inadaptability. The section also covers peripheral nerve conditions such as sciatic radiculopathy, graded from mild incomplete paralysis up to complete paralysis, and Parkinson’s disease (DC 8004) with a 30% minimum.
When it matters & important limits
Headache logs that record prostrating attacks are the evidence this code rewards.Proposed changes pending: VA has proposed updating the neurological rating criteria and has told Congress it expects to finalize the remaining rating-schedule updates, including neurological conditions, by the end of fiscal year 2026. Until a final rule is published, the criteria above apply. Check the eCFR link below for the version currently in effect.
Related court decisions
None collected on this site for this rule. Browse the Case Law Reference →
VA manual procedure
M21-1 V.iii.12.A →
Combined Ratings

The question it answersWhy don’t my ratings simply add up?

38 CFR § 4.25 — Combined Ratings Table ("VA Math")

In plain English
Explains why 50% and 30% do not add up to 80%. Disabilities are combined from most to least severe, each one applied to the "efficiency" left over after the ones before it — a 60% disability leaves you 40% efficient, and a further 30% takes 30% of that remaining 40%, for a combined 72%. The final combined value is then rounded to the nearest 10, so 72% becomes 70%.
When it matters & important limits
The bilateral factor for paired limbs is applied separately under § 4.26.
Related court decisions
None collected on this site for this rule. Browse the Case Law Reference →
VA manual procedure
M21-1 V.iv.1.C →
Official regulation
38 CFR § 4.25 on eCFR ↗
Combined Ratings

The question it answersBoth my knees (or arms, or legs) are rated. Is there an extra step?

38 CFR § 4.26 — The Bilateral Factor

In plain English
An extra step in VA math when disabilities affect both arms, both legs, or paired skeletal muscles. The ratings for those bilateral disabilities are first combined with each other under the combined ratings table, then 10 percent of that combined value is added (not combined) before the result is combined with your other disabilities. For example, two knees rated 10 percent each combine to 19, and 10 percent of 19 is 1.9, so the bilateral value is 20.9 before rounding.
When it matters & important limits
The bilateral factor applies only when both sides are compensable and affected, and it is easy for a rater, or a calculator, to leave out.
Related court decisions
None collected on this site for this rule. Browse the Case Law Reference →
Official regulation
38 CFR § 4.26 on eCFR ↗
Exceptional Cases

The question it answersWhat if the rating schedule doesn’t capture how unusual my disability is?

38 CFR § 3.321 — Extra-Schedular Ratings

In plain English
Allows the VA to assign a rating higher than what the rating schedule would normally permit when a veteran's disability picture is so unusual or exceptional that the schedule does not adequately compensate for the actual functional impairment.
When it matters & important limits
It applies to a single service-connected disability; extra-schedular TDIU is a separate route under § 4.16(b). The test comes from Thun v. Peake: the rating schedule must be inadequate for your disability picture, the picture must show factors such as marked interference with employment or frequent hospitalization, and if both are met the case is referred to the Director of Compensation Service. Rarely invoked but effective when applicable.
Related court decisions
Thun v. Peake (2008)
VA manual procedure
M21-1 V.ii.3.D →
Official regulation
38 CFR § 3.321 on eCFR ↗

↑ Back to the finder

Denials, Reviews & Appeals

Which system your claim is in, the three review lanes after a decision (Supplemental Claim, Higher-Level Review and Board appeal), and the legacy rules that still apply to older claims.

Also relevant: § 3.105 — clear and unmistakable error in a final decision · § 3.103 — notice and hearing rights

Decision Reviews

The question it answersIs my claim under the new appeals system (AMA) or the legacy system?

38 CFR § 3.2400 — Which Claims the Appeals Modernization Act Covers

In plain English
Decides whether your claim is in the modern review system (the AMA) or the legacy system. The AMA rules apply to any claim where VA’s notice of the initial decision was issued on or after February 19, 2019, the date the modernized system took effect. They also apply to an older (legacy) claim that was opted in, either through the RAMP pilot program or by choosing an AMA review option after receiving a Statement of the Case or Supplemental Statement of the Case.
When it matters & important limits
Once a claim is in the AMA, the legacy-only rules (Notices of Disagreement to the regional office, Form 9 substantive appeals, and the “new and material” reopening standard) no longer apply to it. If you are not sure which system your claim is in, check the date of the decision notice.
Related court decisions
None collected on this site for this rule. Browse the Case Law Reference →
VA manual procedure
No M21-1 section is matched to this rule in our index. Browse the M21-1 Manual Index →
Decision Reviews

The question it answersWhich review options do I have after a decision, and how do I keep my effective date?

38 CFR § 3.2500 — Review Options & Continuous Pursuit

In plain English
The traffic-control rule of the Appeals Modernization Act. It lists the review options after a decision — Higher-Level Review, a Board Appeal, or a Supplemental Claim — and bars using two options on the same issue at the same time (§ 3.2500(b)). It also sets out which options remain after each kind of decision (§ 3.2500(c)).
When it matters & important limits
Most important for back pay is § 3.2500(h): if you keep an issue moving by filing the next review within one year, the original effective date is preserved. A Supplemental Claim filed more than a year later is generally limited to an effective date no earlier than its own receipt.
Related court decisions
Calhoun v. McDonough (2024)
VA manual procedure
M21-1 X.ii.2.A →
Supplemental Claims

The question it answersWhat do I need to file a Supplemental Claim?

38 CFR § 3.2501 — Supplemental Claims & New and Relevant Evidence

In plain English
Under the modern Appeals Modernization Act (AMA) system, this is the regulation that governs Supplemental Claims. It defines the standard you have to meet: new evidence, meaning information not previously part of the record, and relevant evidence, meaning it tends to prove or disprove a matter at issue in the claim. By regulation, this standard does not impose a higher evidentiary threshold than the old "new and material" test, and relevant evidence includes evidence that raises a theory of entitlement not previously addressed.
When it matters & important limits
This is one of the most frequently misunderstood standards in the system: veterans often resubmit the same records and are denied because nothing was actually new. A Supplemental Claim can be filed at any time, but your original effective date is preserved only if you file within one year of the decision (§ 3.2500(h)(1), continuous pursuit). If you are filing a Supplemental Claim today, this is your regulation — not § 3.156.
Related court decisions
None collected on this site for this rule. Browse the Case Law Reference →
Decision Reviews

The question it answersHow does a Higher-Level Review work, and what can the reviewer look at?

38 CFR § 3.2601 — Higher-Level Review

In plain English
Governs the Higher-Level Review lane. A complete request must be received within one year of the decision notice, and a more senior adjudicator reviews the issue fresh. The record is closed: the reviewer may consider only the evidence that was in the file when the decision was issued (§ 3.2601(f)).
When it matters & important limits
If the reviewer finds a duty-to-assist error that existed before the decision and cannot grant the maximum benefit, the claim must be returned to correct the error (§ 3.2601(g)). You may also request an informal conference to point the reviewer to the specific error (§ 3.2601(h)).
Related court decisions
None collected on this site for this rule. Browse the Case Law Reference →
VA manual procedure
M21-5 Ch. 5 →
Board Appeals

The question it answersHow do I appeal to the Board, and which docket should I choose?

38 CFR § 20.202 — The Board Appeal (Notice of Disagreement) & Choosing a Docket

In plain English
Governs how you start a Board of Veterans’ Appeals appeal under the AMA. The Notice of Disagreement must be on the prescribed form (VA Form 10182) and must identify the specific decision and issues you are appealing. Any other form or letter does not count and does not stop the clock. On the form you choose one of three dockets (§ 20.202(b)): Direct Review, with no new evidence and no hearing; Evidence Submission, where you may add evidence with the form or within 90 days after it is received; or Hearing, where you may add evidence at the hearing and within 90 days after it.
When it matters & important limits
The docket you pick fixes the evidence the judge can consider. The deadline, generally one year from the date the decision was mailed, is in § 20.203(b), and you can switch dockets within the time limits in § 20.202(c)(2).
Related court decisions
None collected on this site for this rule. Browse the Case Law Reference →
VA manual procedure
This is a Board of Veterans’ Appeals rule. The M21-1 is VBA’s claims-processing manual and does not govern Board appeals.
Board Appeals

The question it answersIf the Board finds VA made an error before deciding my claim, what happens next?

38 CFR § 20.802 — Board Remand to Correct an Error

In plain English
Under the AMA, unless the Board can grant the issue in full, it must send the appeal back (remand it) to the agency of original jurisdiction to correct an error in VA’s duty to assist under 38 U.S.C. § 5103A, as long as the error happened before the decision you appealed (§ 20.802(a)). The Board may also remand to correct any other error in a regulatory or statutory duty if fixing it has a reasonable possibility of helping substantiate your claim. The remand must say what VA has to do.
When it matters & important limits
The duty-to-assist error must have occurred before the decision on appeal. If the only way to fix the error is an advisory medical opinion from an expert who is not a VA employee, the Board remands so the agency of original jurisdiction can get that opinion, and it lists the questions to be asked (§ 20.802(b)).After a remand, the agency of original jurisdiction must correct the error, decide the claim again, send a new decision notice that explains your review options, and treat the remanded claim expeditiously (§ 20.802(c)).
VA manual procedure
This is a Board of Veterans’ Appeals rule. The M21-1 is VBA’s claims-processing manual and does not govern Board appeals.
Legacy & Historical

The question it answersDoes the old “new and material evidence” rule still matter for my claim?

38 CFR § 3.156 — New and Material Evidence (Legacy & Reopening)

In plain English
Frequently cited, frequently misapplied. § 3.156 is the older reopening rule, built around new and material evidence — a higher standard than the AMA's new and relevant test. It still matters in three situations: legacy claims that were pending before the AMA took effect in February 2019, appeals of decisions made under the old system, and § 3.156(c), which governs relevant service department records that existed but were not in the file when the VA first decided the claim.
When it matters & important limits
That last provision is valuable — when newly associated service records reopen a claim, the effective date can reach back to the original claim, not the date of reopening. But if your question is simply "what do I need for a Supplemental Claim," the answer is § 3.2501, not this section.
Related court decisions
None collected on this site for this rule. Browse the Case Law Reference →
VA manual procedure
M21-1 X.ii.2.B →
Official regulation
38 CFR § 3.156 on eCFR ↗

↑ Back to the finder

Effective Dates & Back Pay

When benefits start and how far back pay reaches: the general rule, pending claims, liberalizing laws, Agent Orange (Nehmer) dates and CUE.

Also relevant: § 3.155 — Intent to File · § 3.2500(h) — continuous pursuit · § 3.156(c) — service records found later · § 3.401 — dependent effective dates

Effective Dates

The question it answersWhen do my benefits start, and is my back pay right?

38 CFR § 3.400 — Effective Dates & Back Pay

In plain English
Controls when benefits begin — in other words, how far back your back pay goes. Generally, the effective date is the date the VA receives your claim, but there are important exceptions: Intent to File can set an earlier date, previously denied claims may carry earlier effective dates, and informal claims (for claims before March 24, 2015) can establish dates going back years.
When it matters & important limits
If your effective date seems wrong, this regulation is where to start the argument. Effective date errors are among the most financially significant and most commonly overlooked issues in VA claims.
VA manual procedure
M21-1 V.ii.4.A →
Official regulation
38 CFR § 3.400 on eCFR ↗
Claim Status & Finality

The question it answersIs an old claim still pending, or was it finally decided?

38 CFR § 3.160 — Status of Claims: Pending vs. Finally Adjudicated

In plain English
Defines the vocabulary that decides whether an old claim can still help you. A pending claim is one that has not been finally adjudicated (§ 3.160(c)). A claim becomes finally adjudicated (§ 3.160(d)) when the time to seek review runs out or the review process ends — and the exact trigger differs for legacy claims and claims under the Appeals Modernization Act.
When it matters & important limits
If the VA never properly decided an earlier claim, it may still be pending, which can open the door to an earlier effective date that a new claim never could.
Related court decisions
Rudd v. Nicholson (2006)
VA manual procedure
M21-1 X.ii.1.A →
Official regulation
38 CFR § 3.160 on eCFR ↗
Deadlines

The question it answersHow does VA count the days on a deadline, and what if it lands on a weekend or holiday?

38 CFR § 3.110 — Computation of Time Limit

In plain English
Sets how VA counts the time limit for any action a claimant or beneficiary must take, such as submitting a claim or evidence VA asked for. The first day of the period is not counted and the last day is. If the last day falls on a Saturday, Sunday, or holiday, the deadline moves to the next workday.
When it matters & important limits
The period starts on the date VA mails you notice of what you must do and by when, and the date on the notification letter is treated as the mailing date (§ 3.110(b)). That makes the date printed on your letter the starting point for counting.Board appeals have their own timing rules, which § 3.110(b) points to (38 CFR §§ 19.52, 20.203, and 20.110). An appeal to the Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims is counted under the Court’s own rules, not this section (see the Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims).The Board timing rules: under § 20.203(b), an AMA Notice of Disagreement must be filed with the Board within one year from the date VA mails notice of the decision, and the date on the decision letter is presumed to be the mailing date. The Board can extend that time for good cause if you ask in writing (§ 20.203(c)). Under § 20.110, a document postmarked before the deadline counts as on time. If there is no postmark, it is presumed to have been mailed five days before VA received it, not counting weekends and legal holidays. The same first-day-excluded, last-day-included and next-workday rules apply. For legacy appeals, § 19.52 sets one year for the Notice of Disagreement, 60 days after the Statement of the Case or the rest of the one-year period (whichever ends later) for the Substantive Appeal, and 30 days to respond to a Supplemental Statement of the Case.
Related court decisions
None collected on this site for this rule. Browse the Case Law Reference →
VA manual procedure
Not yet matched on this site. Browse the M21-1 index →
Official regulation
38 CFR § 3.110 on eCFR ↗
Effective Dates — Change of Law

The question it answersHow far back can back pay go when a new law, such as the PACT Act, made me eligible?

38 CFR § 3.114 — Effective Dates After a Liberalizing Law

In plain English
Controls back pay when a benefit is granted because of a new, more favorable law or VA issue — such as a new presumptive condition added by the PACT Act. The effective date cannot be earlier than the date the law or issue took effect, and retroactive payment requires that you met every eligibility requirement on that date and continuously afterward.
When it matters & important limits
How far back the award reaches also depends on when you filed: a claim filed within one year of the law can generally reach back to the law’s effective date, while a later claim is limited to as much as one year before the claim. Filing early matters.
Related court decisions
None collected on this site for this rule. Browse the Case Law Reference →
VA manual procedure
M21-1 V.ii.4.A →
Official regulation
38 CFR § 3.114 on eCFR ↗
Effective Dates — Agent Orange

The question it answersI was denied for a condition later added to the Agent Orange list. Can I get an earlier date?

38 CFR § 3.816 — Nehmer Effective Dates for Agent Orange Claims

In plain English
Implements the court orders in the Nehmer class action. For Vietnam veterans (and certain survivors) with a disease presumptively associated with herbicide exposure under § 3.309(e), other than chloracne, this regulation can produce effective dates far earlier than the ordinary rules allow — in some cases reaching back to an earlier claim that was denied before the disease was added to the presumptive list.
When it matters & important limits
If you were denied for a condition that later became an Agent Orange presumptive, ask whether § 3.816 applies before accepting the effective date you were given.
Official regulation
38 CFR § 3.816 on eCFR ↗
Revising Final Decisions

The question it answersCan I challenge an old, final decision that got the law or facts clearly wrong?

38 CFR § 3.105 — Clear and Unmistakable Error (CUE)

In plain English
Governs the process for challenging final decisions through Clear and Unmistakable Error. A CUE claim requires demonstrating a specific, undebatable error of fact or law in a prior final decision that, had it not occurred, would have manifestly changed the outcome (Russell v. Principi).
When it matters & important limits
The error must be pled with specificity; a general claim that VA got it wrong is not enough (Fugo v. Brown). CUE claims have no deadline and can recover back pay all the way to the original claim date. Understanding this regulation is essential before pursuing a CUE argument.Proposed reductions (§ 3.105(e) and (i)): the same regulation sets the due process VA must follow before reducing a rating that would lower your payments. VA must send a proposal explaining the reasons and give you 60 days to submit evidence that compensation should continue at the present level (§ 3.105(e)). If VA receives a request for a predetermination hearing within 30 days of the notice, payments continue at the current level until VA makes its final decision (§ 3.105(i)). The two periods run at the same time, so a hearing request does not replace sending evidence. See § 3.344 and § 3.951(b) for the five- and 20-year protections.
VA manual procedure
M21-1 X.ii.5.A →
Official regulation
38 CFR § 3.105 on eCFR ↗
Revising Final Decisions

The question it answersCan I challenge a final Board decision that got the law or facts clearly wrong?

38 CFR §§ 20.1400–20.1411 — Revising a Board Decision for Clear and Unmistakable Error

In plain English
§ 3.105(a) covers CUE in regional office decisions. These Board rules (Rules 1400 to 1411) cover a motion asking the Board of Veterans’ Appeals to revise its own final decision. A party to the decision can file the motion, or the Board can start a review on its own (§ 20.1400(a)). Any final Board decision can be revised except on an issue that a court has already decided (§ 20.1400(b)). CUE is “a very specific and rare kind of error” of fact or law that, once pointed out, compels the conclusion, to which reasonable minds could not differ, that the result would have been manifestly different but for the error (§ 20.1403(a)). The review looks only at the record and the law that existed when the Board decided (§ 20.1403(b)).
When it matters & important limits
What is not CUE (§ 20.1403(d)–(e)): a new diagnosis that “corrects” an earlier one, VA’s failure to fulfill the duty to assist, a disagreement with how the facts were weighed, and a later change in how a statute or regulation is interpreted.How to file (§ 20.1404): the motion must be in writing and signed, and give the veteran’s name, the VA file number, the date of the Board decision, and the issues it concerns. It must state clearly and specifically the error, its legal or factual basis, and why the result would have been manifestly different. General allegations, such as a failure to follow regulations or give due process, are not enough, and a motion that falls short is dismissed without prejudice to refiling. A motion may be filed at any time.How it is decided: no new evidence is considered (§ 20.1405(b)). The benefit-of-the-doubt rule does not apply, and the motion carries no duty to assist (§ 20.1411). A motion is not an appeal (§ 20.1402). If it is granted, the revised decision has the same effect as if it had been made on the date of the original decision (§ 20.1406(a)). Once the Board finally decides a motion on an issue, later CUE motions on that same decision and issue are dismissed with prejudice (§ 20.1409(c)), so raise every error in one motion.
VA manual procedure
This is a Board of Veterans’ Appeals rule. The M21-1 is VBA’s claims-processing manual and does not govern Board appeals. For CUE in a regional office decision, see M21-1 X.ii.5.A →

↑ Back to the finder

Protecting Ratings & Additional Benefits

Protection from reductions and severance, permanent and total status, TDIU, Special Monthly Compensation and extra pay for dependents.

Also relevant: § 3.327 — reexaminations · § 3.655 — missing a reexamination

Rating Protection

The question it answersVA wants to reduce my 100% rating or my TDIU. What protects a total rating?

38 CFR § 3.343 — Continuance of Total Disability Ratings

In plain English
Extra protection for total ratings. Under § 3.343(a), a 100% rating based on the severity of a disability will not be reduced, unless it was clear error, without an examination showing material improvement in your physical or mental condition. Under § 3.343(c), a TDIU rating can be reduced only when actual employability is established by clear and convincing evidence.
When it matters & important limits
100% ratings (§ 3.343(a)): VA must weigh the exam against your whole record and consider whether any improvement happened while you were working or looking for work, or only during prolonged rest or a treatment regimen that rules out work. If it is the second, the reduction waits for a reexamination after 3 to 6 months of employment. The protection in (a) does not cover total ratings based on hospital, surgical, or home treatment, or on individual unemployability.TDIU (§ 3.343(c)(1)): A TDIU reduction follows the 60-day notice procedure in § 3.105(e). Going to school, training, or vocational rehabilitation is not by itself a reason to reduce. A reduction may be based on marked improvement, on evidence of employment progress, income, and prospects showing you can do the job you trained for, or on a course whose demands are plainly incompatible with total disability.Getting a job (§ 3.343(c)(2)): If you start a substantially gainful job, TDIU cannot be reduced solely because of that job unless you keep it for 12 consecutive months. Brief, temporary interruptions don’t break the 12 months. You still must report the work.
Related court decisions
None collected on this site for this rule. Browse the Case Law Reference →
VA manual procedure
Not yet matched on this site. Browse the M21-1 index →
Official regulation
38 CFR § 3.343 on eCFR ↗
Rating Protection

The question it answersVA proposed reducing my rating. What protects me?

38 CFR § 3.344 — Protection From Rating Reductions

In plain English
Protects veterans from rating reductions. Under this regulation, ratings in effect for five or more years are generally not reduced unless there is sustained improvement under ordinary conditions of life — not just one better exam. It also requires that a reduction be based on a full and complete examination, not a review exam that is less thorough than the one that established the rating.
When it matters & important limits
This is the regulation raters must follow when proposing a reduction — and the one you cite when challenging one. (The separate 20-year protection, which shields a rating that has been continuously in effect for two decades, comes from § 3.951(b).)Ratings in effect less than five years (§ 3.344(c)): the protections in paragraphs (a) and (b) apply to ratings that have continued at the same level for five years or more. They do not apply to disabilities that have not become stabilized and are likely to improve; for those, a reexamination that shows improvement, physical or mental, warrants a reduction. So a rating in effect less than five years isn’t covered by (a) and (b), and for a disability that hasn’t stabilized, a reexamination showing improvement can support a reduction. The notice, 60-day evidence, and hearing steps in § 3.105(e) and (i) still apply when the reduction would lower your payments.
Related court decisions
Kitchens v. Brown (1995)
VA manual procedure
M21-1 X.ii.4.A, X.ii.4.B →
Official regulation
38 CFR § 3.344 on eCFR ↗
Rating Protection

The question it answersMy rating has been in place for 20 years, or the rating schedule changed. Can it still be reduced?

38 CFR § 3.951 — Preservation of Disability Ratings (the 20-Year Rule)

In plain English
Two protections in one regulation. Under § 3.951(a), a change to the rating schedule is not a reason to reduce a rating you already have unless medical evidence shows the disability actually improved. Under § 3.951(b), a disability that has been continuously rated at or above a level for 20 or more years cannot be reduced below that level except on a showing of fraud.
When it matters & important limits
The 20 years run from the effective date of the evaluation. Check your award history — a long-held rating may be protected even without permanent and total status.
Related court decisions
None collected on this site for this rule. Browse the Case Law Reference →
VA manual procedure
M21-1 X.ii.1.B →
Official regulation
38 CFR § 3.951 on eCFR ↗
Rating Protection

The question it answersCan VA take away service connection I’ve had for 10 years?

38 CFR § 3.957 — Protection of Service Connection After 10 Years

In plain English
Once service connection has been in effect for 10 or more years, it cannot be severed unless the original grant was based on fraud, or military records clearly show you did not have the required service or character of discharge. The 10 years are measured from the effective date of service connection to the effective date of the severance, after the severance procedures in § 3.105(d) are followed.
When it matters & important limits
This protects the service connection itself — the rating percentage is protected separately under § 3.344 and § 3.951.
Examples & practical guides
Related court decisions
None collected on this site for this rule. Browse the Case Law Reference →
VA manual procedure
M21-1 X.ii.1.B →
Official regulation
38 CFR § 3.957 on eCFR ↗
Total & Permanent

The question it answersWhat does “permanent and total” mean, and what does it unlock?

38 CFR § 3.340 — Total and Permanent Total Ratings

In plain English
Defines the two words in “P&T.” Total disability exists when any impairment of mind or body makes it impossible for the average person to follow a substantially gainful occupation. It can be based on a 100 percent schedular rating or on individual unemployability under § 4.16. Permanence of total disability exists when the impairment is reasonably certain to continue throughout the person’s life (§ 3.340(b)).
When it matters & important limits
Age may be considered when deciding permanence. This is different from the TDIU decision itself, where age cannot be considered under § 3.341. A permanent and total finding usually means no routine future exams, and it unlocks benefits for your family such as DEA (Chapter 35) and, if you otherwise qualify, CHAMPVA.
Related court decisions
None collected on this site for this rule. Browse the Case Law Reference →
Official regulation
38 CFR § 3.340 on eCFR ↗
Total Disability — TDIU

The question it answersCan VA deny TDIU because of my age or non-service-connected conditions?

38 CFR § 3.341 — Total Disability Ratings for Compensation (Including Age)

In plain English
The Part 3 gateway to TDIU. A total disability rating for compensation may be assigned when the veteran is unable to secure or follow a substantially gainful occupation because of service-connected disability, under the standards in § 4.16.
When it matters & important limits
Section 3.341(a) has one rule veterans should know by heart: when the rating schedule gives your disabilities less than 100 percent, unemployability must be found without regard to advancing age. A denial that leans on your age, or on non-service-connected conditions, applies the wrong standard. The question is whether your service-connected disabilities alone keep you from substantially gainful work (Ray v. Wilkie). And a request for TDIU does not have to be a separate claim. It is part of an increased-rating claim whenever the record raises unemployability (Rice v. Shinseki).
Official regulation
38 CFR § 3.341 on eCFR ↗
Total Disability

The question it answersI can’t work because of my service-connected disabilities. Do I qualify for TDIU?

38 CFR § 4.16 — TDIU: Total Disability Based on Individual Unemployability

In plain English
The regulatory basis for TDIU. Subsection (a) governs Schedular TDIU — the rating thresholds (single condition at 60%+, or combined 70%+ with one at 40%+) and the unemployability requirement. Subsection (b) governs Extra-Schedular TDIU for veterans who do not meet the thresholds but whose disabilities make substantially gainful employment unfeasible.
When it matters & important limits
Every TDIU claim and denial is adjudicated under this regulation. TDIU does not need a separate claim when the record shows you cannot work (Rice v. Shinseki), “substantially gainful” has both an economic and a non-economic side (Ray v. Wilkie), and age may not be considered (§ 3.341). A total rating that is also permanent is defined in § 3.340.
Official regulation
38 CFR § 4.16 on eCFR ↗
Special Monthly Compensation

The question it answersAm I entitled to Special Monthly Compensation on top of my rating?

38 CFR § 3.350 — Special Monthly Compensation (SMC)

In plain English
SMC is paid on top of, or in place of, the regular schedular rate for especially serious losses. The levels are named for the letters of 38 U.S.C. § 1114. SMC(k) is a fixed add-on for things such as the loss or loss of use of a hand, a foot or a creative organ, or blindness in one eye. SMC(l) through (o) cover severe combinations, such as the loss of use of both feet, or needing the regular aid and attendance of another person. SMC(r) is for veterans who need a higher level of aid and attendance, and SMC(t) is for veterans who need aid and attendance because of a traumatic brain injury. SMC(s), the “housebound” rate, applies when you have one disability rated 100 percent plus additional disabilities independently rated 60 percent or more, or when you are permanently housebound in fact because of service-connected disability.
When it matters & important limits
The criteria for needing aid and attendance are in § 3.352. VA is supposed to consider SMC whenever the record supports it, even if you never asked.
Related court decisions
Akles v. Derwinski (1991), Bradley v. Peake (2008), Buie v. Shinseki (2011), Turco v. Brown (1996), and Breniser v. Shinseki (2011) are explained in the SMC Guide →
VA manual procedure
M21-1 VIII.iv.4.A →
Official regulation
38 CFR § 3.350 on eCFR ↗
Special Monthly Compensation

The question it answersWhat does VA look at to decide whether I need aid and attendance?

38 CFR § 3.352 — Criteria for Needing Aid and Attendance

In plain English
Lists what VA considers when deciding whether you need the regular aid and attendance of another person (§ 3.352(a)): being unable to dress or undress or to keep yourself ordinarily clean and presentable; frequently needing help adjusting a special prosthetic or orthopedic appliance; being unable to feed yourself because of loss of coordination in the arms or extreme weakness; being unable to attend to the wants of nature; or a physical or mental incapacity that requires care or assistance on a regular basis to protect you from the hazards or dangers of your daily environment. Being actually bedridden, meaning your condition requires you to stay in bed, is also a basis.
When it matters & important limits
Not all of the listed conditions have to be found. The evidence must show you need regular aid and attendance, not constant help, and the decision must rest on an actual need for personal assistance from others, not only on an opinion that you should be in bed (§ 3.352(a)). Help provided by a relative or another member of your household does not prevent the award (§ 3.352(c)).Higher level of care (§ 3.352(b)): the higher aid and attendance allowance requires, among other things, a need for daily personal health-care services in your home, such as physical therapy, injections, catheter placement or sterile dressing changes, given by a licensed health-care professional or by someone a licensed professional supervises and consults with at least monthly. Without that care you would need hospitalization, nursing home care or other institutional care. It applies to veterans entitled to SMC(o) or the maximum SMC(p) rate (§ 3.350(h)) or, for residuals of traumatic brain injury, under § 3.350(j). These provisions are strictly construed.
VA manual procedure
M21-1 VIII.iv.4.A →
Official regulation
38 CFR § 3.352 on eCFR ↗
Compensation & Dependents

The question it answersWhen does VA pay extra for my spouse, children or dependent parents?

38 CFR § 3.4 — Compensation, Including Extra Pay for Dependents at 30%

In plain English
The basic compensation rule. Disability compensation is a monthly payment for a service-connected disability (§ 3.4(b)(1)). Under § 3.4(b)(2), a veteran whose disability is rated 30 percent or more is entitled to additional compensation for a spouse, children and dependent parents. The 30 percent is the veteran’s combined rating, and below it no dependent amount is paid.
When it matters & important limits
If you are at 30 percent or higher and have never added your family, VA will not do it for you. Add them on VA Form 21-686c, and file promptly, because the effective date of the added amount depends on timing under § 3.401(b).
Related court decisions
None collected on this site for this rule. Browse the Case Law Reference →
Official regulation
38 CFR § 3.4 on eCFR ↗
Effective Dates — Dependents

The question it answersWhen does the added pay for a dependent start?

38 CFR § 3.401 — Effective Dates for Dependents & Other Awards

In plain English
Sets effective dates for specific kinds of awards, alongside the general rule in § 3.400. The provision veterans use most is § 3.401(b), for the additional amount paid for a dependent. The effective date is the latest of: the date of claim; the date dependency arises; the effective date of the qualifying disability rating, if evidence of the dependent is received within one year of VA’s notice of that rating; or the date the veteran’s award began.
When it matters & important limits
Two one-year windows matter here. A marriage, birth or adoption reported within one year of the event can be paid from the event date. And when a new rating first takes you to 30 percent, sending in your dependent information within one year of the decision notice can make the dependent amount start on the rating’s effective date instead of the later date you reported.
Related court decisions
None collected on this site for this rule. Browse the Case Law Reference →
Official regulation
38 CFR § 3.401 on eCFR ↗

↑ Back to the finder

VA Health Care

Enrollment in VA health care and the priority groups that set enrollment order and many copays.

Also relevant: VA Healthcare Guide

VA Health Care

The question it answersCan I enroll in VA health care, and which priority group am I in?

38 CFR § 17.36 — Enrollment & Priority Groups

In plain English
Controls enrollment in VA health care and the eight priority groups that determine the order of enrollment and many copays. Priority Group 1 covers veterans with service-connected disabilities rated 50 percent or more, or found unemployable (TDIU). Priority Group 2 is for ratings of 30 or 40 percent. Priority Group 3 includes ratings of 10 or 20 percent, former prisoners of war, Purple Heart recipients and veterans discharged for a disability incurred or aggravated in the line of duty. The lower groups are based on factors such as other special eligibility and income.
When it matters & important limits
A rating increase can move you into a higher group, and treatment of a service-connected condition is free in any group. This is a Veterans Health Administration rule, so it has no M21-1 counterpart.
Related court decisions
None collected on this site for this rule. Browse the Case Law Reference →
VA manual procedure
This is a Veterans Health Administration rule, so it has no M21-1 counterpart.
Official regulation
38 CFR § 17.36 on eCFR ↗

↑ Back to the finder

Why Regulations Matter

When a VA rater issues your decision, they are required to follow specific federal regulations codified in Title 38 of the Code of Federal Regulations (38 CFR). When a rater violates or misapplies these regulations, that is a legal error — and legal errors are exactly what Higher-Level Reviews and BVA appeals are designed to catch and correct.

Most veterans never look at the regulations. That is a significant disadvantage. A veteran who knows that 38 CFR § 3.102 legally requires the VA to resolve reasonable doubt in their favor — and can cite it in an appeal — is in a fundamentally different position than one who simply says "I think the decision was wrong." Citations carry weight. Raters and judges are required to address them.

The M21-1 Adjudication Procedures Manual is a different kind of document: it is the VA's internal instructions to its own claims processors — the step-by-step playbook for how claims are supposed to be developed and rated. It is guidance for VBA employees rather than law, so it does not carry the same weight as a regulation or a court decision. It is still useful, and knowing exactly how it differs from 38 CFR is part of using either one well. There is a side-by-side 38 CFR vs. M21-1 breakdown further down this page.

💡

How to Use These Regulations

When writing an appeal or personal statement, cite the specific regulation that supports your argument. For example: "Under 38 CFR § 3.102, when there is an approximate balance of positive and negative evidence, the benefit of the doubt shall be given to the claimant. The evidence in this case is at minimum in equipoise and therefore service connection must be granted." That language strengthens your position and requires the rater to address the regulation directly — it is not something they can simply set aside.

38 CFR vs. M21-1: What's the Difference?

Three different kinds of authority govern your claim, and they do not carry equal weight. Veterans lose arguments by treating an internal VA instruction as though it overrides a regulation, or by citing a manual provision when a binding court decision would have settled the point. Here is how the three fit together.

Binding Law

38 CFR — Federal Regulations

Rules the VA issued through formal public rulemaking and published in the Code of Federal Regulations. They carry the force of law. Raters, the Board of Veterans' Appeals, and the courts are all bound by them. When a regulation and an internal instruction point in different directions, the regulation controls.

Use it to: establish the legal right or standard you are entitled to. This is the strongest citation available to most veterans.

Internal Guidance

M21-1 — VA's Adjudication Manual

VBA's internal procedural instructions to its own claims processors and raters. The manual was not issued through rulemaking and is not law. It directs how VBA employees are supposed to do their work, but it cannot create a benefit the regulations do not provide or take one away — and it is generally not binding on the Board the way 38 CFR is.

Use it to: show that the VA skipped a development step its own procedures required — always alongside the regulation or case law that establishes the underlying right.

Binding Precedent

Case Law — Court Decisions

Decisions of the Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims and the Federal Circuit interpreting the statutes and regulations. A precedential decision tells everyone — including the VA — what a regulation actually means, and it binds VA adjudicators nationwide. Federal Circuit decisions bind the CAVC, and Supreme Court decisions — such as Bufkin v. Collins (2025) — bind both courts.

Read: VA Case Law Reference — Gilbert, DeLuca, Caluza and more →

💡

The Order of Authority

Statute beats regulation. Regulation beats the manual. And a precedential court decision tells you what the statute or regulation actually means. So when you build an argument, lead with the strongest authority you have — the regulation or the case — and bring in the M21-1 to show the VA departed from its own procedures. An M21-1 citation on its own is the weakest version of a good argument.

The M21-1 Adjudication Manual: The VA's Internal Playbook

The M21-1, often called the VA rater's handbook, is the VA's internal procedures manual for claims processors and raters. It translates the regulations into step-by-step instructions for how claims are supposed to be handled: when to request records, when an exam is required, what a rating decision has to document. When a rater departs from it, that is evidence the claim was not developed the way the agency itself requires, and it is worth raising. It is still internal guidance, not a source of law, and under 38 CFR § 20.105 the Board is not bound by it.

The M21-1 is published free on VA's KnowVA site. It was reorganized in 2021, so older citations using pre-2021 chapter numbers may point to moved or renamed sections. Higher-Level Review procedures are in a separate manual, the M21-5.

Manual Index

M21-1 Sections for Every Regulation on This Page

Our M21-1 Manual Index pairs each regulation above with the M21-1 or M21-5 section that applies it, using the official KnowVA section titles and links. It covers duty to assist, service connection, presumptives, effective dates, decision reviews, rating protection and the Part 4 rating schedule. Each regulation block on this page also links to its index entry.

Open the M21-1 Index →
M21-1, Table of Contents

Full M21-1 Table of Contents

The complete M21-1 with all parts and chapters, on KnowVA. KnowVA needs JavaScript turned on to display articles.

M21-1 Table of Contents →
⚠️

Regulations Change — Always Verify

38 CFR is amended periodically and the M21-1 is updated frequently. The links above go to the current official versions. If you are researching a decision made years ago, the regulation that was in effect at the time of the decision controls — not the current version. An accredited attorney or VSO can help you identify which version applied to your specific claim date.

Official Sources

The complete, current text of every regulation governing VA disability claims is publicly available at no cost. Bookmark these sources.

Primary Source

38 CFR — Full Text (eCFR)

The Electronic Code of Federal Regulations. Always current. Title 38 covers all VA regulations. Part 3 governs claims; Part 4 is the rating schedule.

Browse 38 CFR →
Internal Manual

M21-1 Adjudication Manual

The VA's complete internal procedures manual for claims processors. Searchable by topic. The authoritative source for how the VA is supposed to handle your claim at every step.

Access M21-1 →
Federal Register

Proposed & Final Rules

When VA proposes changes to regulations, they publish in the Federal Register. Following this lets you know when regulations affecting your claim are changing — sometimes with comment periods where veterans can weigh in.

VA Federal Register →
VA Law Library

VA Office of General Counsel

The VA's own legal interpretations and precedent opinions. When the OGC issues a precedent opinion on how a regulation should be applied, it binds VA adjudicators nationwide. Useful for complex regulatory arguments.

OGC Precedent Opinions →